ziggystardust wrote: skullman80 wrote:
ziggystardust wrote:how do people like Scuds but not Melichar?
how do people like Leclair, Malone and Whitney?
how do people like Gonchar?
None of that makes any sense.
Perhaps not everyone has the exact same opinion you do?
How could you like someone who is grossly overpaid?
Or someone like Whitney who has regressed so much as the season has gone on?
Or Malone, someone who has underperformed so dramatically, and looked lazy so many times??
liking those players is completely illogical.
I have no problems with Gonchar. Yeah he was terrible at the beginning of the season, he has played well as of late. Salary wise...that's not his fault. If anything I should ***** at CP for giving him 5 mil a year. He is in the top 10 for Defensemen in terms of scoring.
Whitney once again no problem with. He has had his share of growing pains, but that is to be expected since he is a rookie. His play in his own end willl improve over time, IMO and I like the way he can bring the puck up the ice, probably our best puck carrying defenseman.
Malone is kinda "eh" with me. I like that he has picked up his play, but I don't think he will ever be more than a 3rd line center on a good team.
What about you boy Melichar yesterday? Played horribly...you should stop liking him now, right?
All that I'm saying is people have different reasons for liking certain players. For you to pass judgement off on them is pretty silly just because they don't agree with your opinion.