So is it too early for? *revised 10-23*

[Daniel87]

Am I the only one that thinks Malkin rode Sidney's coattails a bit on Saturday?

Don't get me wrong, Malkin was great and part of Crosby's success on Saturday was due to him, but I just thought Crosby's 4pts were far more impressive (the way he got them) than Malkin's 4pts).

I don't think anyone thought Malkin had a more impressive game then Crosby on Saturday. The "who's better" debate will go on for years, but there's no doubt Crosby was more impressive then Malkin Saturday.

[Idoit40fans]

Am I the only one that thinks Malkin rode Sidney's coattails a bit on Saturday?

Don't get me wrong, Malkin was great and part of Crosby's success on Saturday was due to him, but I just thought Crosby's 4pts were far more impressive (the way he got them) than Malkin's 4pts).

I don't think anyone thought Malkin had a more impressive game then Crosby on Saturday. The "who's better" debate will go on for years, but there's no doubt Crosby was more impressive then Malkin Saturday.

So what you're saying is that you hate Malkin?

[Sabres_Fan]

Well, Thomas Vanek is "on pace" for 115 goals.

115 goals yeah right... I can see him get 136 goals but now way 115 goals.

[wm0712]

Am I the only one that thinks Malkin rode Sidney's coattails a bit on Saturday?

Don't get me wrong, Malkin was great and part of Crosby's success on Saturday was due to him, but I just thought Crosby's 4pts were far more impressive (the way he got them) than Malkin's 4pts).

well you could say the same things about the other night against washington where sids points were weak and came from malkin shooting... it goes both ways

[Kovy27]

Pascal agrees with me...

"(Crosby) is the best player in the league," said Crosby linemate Pascal Dupuis, who also scored. "It's always good to play with a guy like that."

[Idoit40fans]

Pascal agrees with me...

"(Crosby) is the best player in the league," said Crosby linemate Pascal Dupuis, who also scored. "It's always good to play with a guy like that."

Nope, he's agreeing with me.

[Kovy27]

Pascal agrees with me...

"(Crosby) is the best player in the league," said Crosby linemate Pascal Dupuis, who also scored. "It's always good to play with a guy like that."

Nope, he's agreeing with me.

Who agreed with me.

[Idoit40fans]

I'm better.

[Stan Potash]

somebody please remember that PensFanInDC said malkin will have 150 points at the end of the season.

wow. i really hope you were kidding.

[Pitts]

How the hell does Semin have 10 points?

Easy. He's currently the BEST player in the NHL.

[TheTimeHasCome]

I really love this thread.... time for an update

Player Team GP G A P
1 Evgeni Malkin PIT 7 2 9 11
2 Alexander Semin WSH 6 6 4 10
3 Patrick Sharp CHI 7 5 5 10
4 Paul Stastny COL 6 1 9 10
5 Paul Kariya STL 6 1 9 10
13 Sidney Crosby PIT 7 1 8 9

[Digitalgypsy66]

I really like Patrick Sharp. Anytime I see highlights or flip by a Hawks game, it seems like he is either scoring or getting a solid scoring chance. He has some speed and grit...and the Flyers gave him up for a scrub and pick they traded to Montreal.

[Kovy27]

Is this the year?

[Mongoose87]

Is this the year?

No, that's next year.

[Daniel87]

Am I the only one that thinks Malkin rode Sidney's coattails a bit on Saturday?

Don't get me wrong, Malkin was great and part of Crosby's success on Saturday was due to him, but I just thought Crosby's 4pts were far more impressive (the way he got them) than Malkin's 4pts).

I don't think anyone thought Malkin had a more impressive game then Crosby on Saturday. The "who's better" debate will go on for years, but there's no doubt Crosby was more impressive then Malkin Saturday.

So what you're saying is that you hate Malkin?

Um, no. He's my 2nd favorite player, behind Talbot.