Moderators: Three Stars, dagny, pfim, netwolf
Reilly wrote:McCabe is no Norris defenseman.
HomerPenguin wrote:How do you give this award to anybody other than Lyle Odelein? Are you guys all on crack?
Reilly wrote:McCabe is no Norris defenseman.
pfim wrote:McCabe is having a good offensive half-season, but defensively he isn't in the class of a Pronger, Chara, Lidstrom etc.
bse wrote:pfim wrote:McCabe is having a good offensive half-season, but defensively he isn't in the class of a Pronger, Chara, Lidstrom etc.
Defensively he is having just as good season as Lidström or Pronger. Redden and Chara, as they are playing for the Senators, have better +/- than pretty much anyone.
pfim wrote:bse wrote:pfim wrote:McCabe is having a good offensive half-season, but defensively he isn't in the class of a Pronger, Chara, Lidstrom etc.
Defensively he is having just as good season as Lidström or Pronger. Redden and Chara, as they are playing for the Senators, have better +/- than pretty much anyone.
So why not Lubomir Visnovsky? If +/- was the best way to measure a defenseman defensively, Michal Roszival would be considered a great defensive defenseman. If you're saying that McCabe is better defensively than Lidstrom or Pronger, I disagree completely, this season, last season, whenever.
Users browsing this forum: MWW and 14 guests