pugilist13 wrote:Bowser wrote:Craig Patrick was justly ripped for having terrible drafts from 94-99 and since drafting Jordan Staal number two overall in 2006, the highest goal scoring forward is Dustin Jeffrey with 12 goals in 67 games.
Craig Partrick from 94-99
99 - Ryan Malone 171 goals, Tom Kostopolous 60 goals
98 - Milan Kraft 41 goals, Toby Petersen 33
95 - Alexei Morozov 84, Jan Hrdina 101
94 - Richard Park 102, Serge Aubin 44
Ray Shero from 06-12 (any goal scorer at F)
12 - none
11 - none
10 - none
09 - none
08 - none
07 - Luca Caputi 3, Dustin Jeffrey 12
06 - Jordan Staal 120
Pathetic doesn't even describe Shero's work in the draft at forward.
The knock on Patrick was ignoring defensemen, from 94-99 he drafted these guys who played at least 1 game in NHL
94 - Sven Butenschoen
95 - none
96 - Pavel Skrbek, Michal Rozsival
97 - Josef Melichar, Andrew Ference
98 - Rob Scuderi
99 - none
Wow. That is pathetic at forward. You dont realize it until you see it. Thanks for digging this up.
It takes 5 years IMHO to determine whether a drafted prospect is a bust or not. This assumes you are not talking about a top 5 guy who should impact the NHL team sooner. You started in 2006, well Shero picked Staal for better or worse, the rest of that draft was by Greg Malone and the old scouting staff. So in reality Shero's first full draft was 2007. Anyway here are my comments on those drafts from the forward position. I think you paint a picture that is too dire and isn't reality.
Ray Shero from 06-12 (any goal scorer at F)
12 - none (Way too early to judge, but both Bluger and Zlobin have a chance to make the NHL roster some day)
11 - none (Again too early, but Archibald and Wilson both have a chance.)
10 - none (Bennett will make the NHL and Agostino might)
09 - none (Agree here no forward prospects coming from this group)
08 - none (Draft essentially given away to get Hossa and Gill)
07 - Luca Caputi 3, Dustin Jeffrey 12 (Nothing beyond these two are NHL'ers)
06 - Jordan Staal 120 (See my original statement)
I guess to summarize, they don't have 5 first round picks at forward who are locks to make a NHL impact, but they do have a few players at forward who could make an impact in the next year or two.







