NashvilleCat wrote: murphydump55 wrote: NashvilleCat wrote: murphydump55 wrote:
NashvilleCat wrote:3 goals 6 assists in 9 games playing with a bunch of nobodies.
Yup, that's what i said.
You said he's a joke. I'll take that joke for 82 games.
He is...at times, and I'm not wrong saying that.
You were talking about him like he's an unqualified bust. He's off to a great start. Sid makes some goofy plays too. You take what you get with him. Bottom line is he's one of the top 4 forwards in hockey no matter what you think.
Never said he was a bust. I said he's one of the top talents in the game when he's on. The problem is he has far too much trouble finding his on switch. That's my biggest gripe with him. When he's on, he's unbelievable, and probably challenges Sid for tops in the game. When he's off, he's downright lost, horrible decisions, horrible passes, lazy, bad penalties, etc.
He needs to work on that consistency, it can't be happening as this point in his career. He's been better this year but still has way too many inexcusable plays at times.