The Battle of Gettysburg **Game Thread**

[Kraftster]

Gah good game everyone. Thanks thg for
Running the show, it was fun. We totally screwed the pooch on this one and rylans inactivity killed us; hope he is okay tho. He just disappeared. And our kill on troy ugh so bad after we saw him. Lol oops

Ha, I was wondering what was going on with that one!

Thanks, thg.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Good game. But did I really die? lol

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Thanks for modding thg

[the wicked child]

My only criticism of this game is that I think ps87, IE and Rylan all should have been modkilled. Life happens, but not posting for as long as they did really hurts the game. It's not fair to the rest of the players when votes get dragged out for 12+ hours because people aren't around.

Otherwise enjoyable.

[IrishEyes]

My only criticism of this game is that I think ps87, IE and Rylan all should have been modkilled. Life happens, but not posting for as long as they did really hurts the game. It's not fair to the rest of the players when votes get dragged out for 12+ hours because people aren't around.

Otherwise enjoyable.

Being one of those people, I do agree with that. Like I said in the dead thread, I am terribly sorry for disappearing. But great job bhaw!

THG, great game, even though I wasn't around.

[mac5155]

yep, i'm not going to criticize thg because it was the players' faults that the game went on for so long. good game, thanks!

[newarenanow]

Good game thg.

[Troy Loney]

Gah good game everyone. Thanks thg for
Running the show, it was fun. We totally screwed the pooch on this one and rylans inactivity killed us; hope he is okay tho. He just disappeared. And our kill on troy ugh so bad after we saw him. Lol oops

The village killing IE made zero sense there.

I couldn't understand why you guys killed ps87 when you did. That kill prolonged the game. If you had killed sdd or mwb the game would have been over.

[Zarovich]

Gah good game everyone. Thanks thg for
Running the show, it was fun. We totally screwed the pooch on this one and rylans inactivity killed us; hope he is okay tho. He just disappeared. And our kill on troy ugh so bad after we saw him. Lol oops

The village killing IE made zero sense there.

I couldn't understand why you guys killed ps87 when you did. That kill prolonged the game. If you had killed sdd or mwb the game would have been over.

If ps87 had not shown up, I would have killed sdd. I would have voted bhaw hoping mwb would also. Since ps87 showed, he was a wildcard and I had no clue what he would do. I felt I had a better chance of getting sdd to flip than not knowing ps87 was at. I took a chance and bhaw almost got sdd to vote for me.

[ExPatriatePen]

Wow, I love the smell of gun powder in the morning.

Who's gonna burry all of these dead bodies now?

THG, you did appoint one player as the undertaker didn't you?

[Benny Fitz]

Wow, I love the smell of gun powder in the morning.

Who's gonna burry all of these dead bodies now?

THG, you did appoint one player as the undertaker didn't you?

EPP if i tell you something, will you promise not to change a thing?

[bhaw]

I hear EPP loves the, uh, smell of dead bodies. I nominate him!

[bhaw]

Gah good game everyone. Thanks thg for
Running the show, it was fun. We totally screwed the pooch on this one and rylans inactivity killed us; hope he is okay tho. He just disappeared. And our kill on troy ugh so bad after we saw him. Lol oops

The village killing IE made zero sense there.

I couldn't understand why you guys killed ps87 when you did. That kill prolonged the game. If you had killed sdd or mwb the game would have been over.

If ps87 had not shown up, I would have killed sdd. I would have voted bhaw hoping mwb would also. Since ps87 showed, he was a wildcard and I had no clue what he would do. I felt I had a better chance of getting sdd to flip than not knowing ps87 was at. I took a chance and bhaw almost got sdd to vote for me.

It was a last ditch effort. I was hoping SDD held out for long enough to convince MWB. My rationale was true though. With 2 left, a tie was a loss for the blue/green team.

[ExPatriatePen]

Wow, I love the smell of gun powder in the morning.

Who's gonna burry all of these dead bodies now?

THG, you did appoint one player as the undertaker didn't you?

EPP if i tell you something, will you promise not to change a thing?

[Benny Fitz]

Wow, I love the smell of gun powder in the morning.

Who's gonna burry all of these dead bodies now?

THG, you did appoint one player as the undertaker didn't you?

EPP if i tell you something, will you promise not to change a thing?

you're the wink potentate.

[ExPatriatePen]

LOL I does luvs my emoticons...

[Benny Fitz]

LOL I does luvs my emoticons...

i'm too am a fan.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

I was going to vote for bhaw if I thought it meant the village could win, but the chance of another red being out there kept me hopeful that we could convince MWB to change his vote. If MWB hadn't changed his vote prior to when I came back from walking my dogs I probably would have voted for bhaw.

[redwill]

Well done, bhaw, MWB, Zaro, and SDD.

Like Benny said, the last few phases epitomized what this game can be at its best. It was very fun to watch.

Thanks, thg!

[MWB]

Gah good game everyone. Thanks thg for
Running the show, it was fun. We totally screwed the pooch on this one and rylans inactivity killed us; hope he is okay tho. He just disappeared. And our kill on troy ugh so bad after we saw him. Lol oops

The village killing IE made zero sense there.

I couldn't understand why you guys killed ps87 when you did. That kill prolonged the game. If you had killed sdd or mwb the game would have been over.

If he had targeted me, he would have died as well though.

[Letang Is The Truth]

Gah good game everyone. Thanks thg for
Running the show, it was fun. We totally screwed the pooch on this one and rylans inactivity killed us; hope he is okay tho. He just disappeared. And our kill on troy ugh so bad after we saw him. Lol oops

The village killing IE made zero sense there.

I couldn't understand why you guys killed ps87 when you did. That kill prolonged the game. If you had killed sdd or mwb the game would have been over.

If he had targeted me, he would have died as well though.

which is why we never shot you lol

[ExPatriatePen]

Gah good game everyone. Thanks thg for
Running the show, it was fun. We totally screwed the pooch on this one and rylans inactivity killed us; hope he is okay tho. He just disappeared. And our kill on troy ugh so bad after we saw him. Lol oops

The village killing IE made zero sense there.

I couldn't understand why you guys killed ps87 when you did. That kill prolonged the game. If you had killed sdd or mwb the game would have been over.

If he had targeted me, he would have died as well though.

which is why we never shot you lol

How does that work? MWB was a vig? And he had a bullet that would take out his killer?

[redwill]

How does that work? MWB was a vig? And he had a bullet that would take out his killer?

It's up to the mod. Some mods put in the rule that if the vigilante is targeted AND he/she has an unused bullet, the Alpha baddie dies as well (or even instead). I go back and forth on this rule when I mod. It makes sense (you have a loaded gun and someone tries to kill you ... you kill him), but it really seems to be a real detriment to the reds. The vig isn't that important of a role, and the Alpha is very important. I've had it set up both ways in games I've modded.

[Letang Is The Truth]

sometimes if the vig has a bullet stored and does it use it, when they are attacked at night, the person attacking will get shot from that bullet. its a little added protection and it encourages you not to fire if you arent 100% sure

[MWB]

How does that work? MWB was a vig? And he had a bullet that would take out his killer?

It's up to the mod. Some mods put in the rule that if the vigilante is targeted AND he/she has an unused bullet, the Alpha baddie dies as well (or even instead). I go back and forth on this rule when I mod. It makes sense (you have a loaded gun and someone tries to kill you ... you kill him), but it really seems to be a real detriment to the reds. The vig isn't that important of a role, and the Alpha is very important. I've had it set up both ways in games I've modded.

Yeah, this was how THG had it set up. I think it was balanced out some by if I used the shot, I'd be susceptible to a kill that night and the next (my reload night), without anything happening to the person killing me.