WWXX GAMEPLAY THREAD

[count2infinity]

yeah...he is. not sure what pavel is saying there....

[Willie Kool]

I don't know about columbia. Kraftster and redwill, as good players, would be targets for anyone. At this point I think I like nan's vote yesterday for thg.
Lynch thg

[columbia]

wait he's going after Columbia isn't he?

Indeed.

[shafnutz05]

I don't know about columbia. Kraftster and redwill, as good players, would be targets for anyone. At this point I think I like nan's vote yesterday for thg.
Lynch thg

This was kind of my thought. Despite columbia coming after me, I'm not really sold that he is bad. It just seems like way too obvious of a set up.

[Pavel Bure]

wait he's going after Columbia isn't he?

You're right Sorry I just woke up. I meant columbia not shaf. It still holds true, a woflie going after someone just cause they voted for them in a game this big doesn't make sense at all and crpl seems to be trying to reason into that real hard.

[Benny Fitz]

ahh arent you guys (+2girls) forgetting something?

The way I view being a target of a bandwagon:

1. If I'm red, I'll eventually claim to be the Angel.
2. If I'm green, I'll eventually claim my actual role.

Since I won't be doing either, I think you can determine what I am.

columbia already told us he was blue....

[Pavel Bure]

ahh arent you guys (+2girls) forgetting something?

The way I view being a target of a bandwagon:

1. If I'm red, I'll eventually claim to be the Angel.
2. If I'm green, I'll eventually claim my actual role.

Since I won't be doing either, I think you can determine what I am.

columbia already told us he was blue....

And I'm a Knight from King Arthur's court. If I said it, it must be true

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

ahh arent you guys (+2girls) forgetting something?

The way I view being a target of a bandwagon:

1. If I'm red, I'll eventually claim to be the Angel.
2. If I'm green, I'll eventually claim my actual role.

Since I won't be doing either, I think you can determine what I am.

columbia already told us he was blue....

And we should believe him because he is just so trustworthy? Not that I have a reason to doubt his claim, but I am not going to totally discount him because he or anyone for that matter says they are blue.

[columbia]

Meh. If nothing else, you're just proving that saying nothing early on is the best course and that leads to very dull games.

[Malkamaniac]

lol people actually trust each other in these games?!

[shafnutz05]

Meh. If nothing else, you're just proving that saying nothing early on is the best course and that leads to very dull games.

I actually agree with you on this. I would MUCH rather get rid of someone that hasn't contributed thus far. The reason why I voted for LITT is he met two of my criteria. Hasn't contributed anything, and came in quietly late on a bandwagon.

I have gotten screwed in the past because I'm tried to contribute, while people that have a grand total of one post somehow make it to like the last five people. Hence why I am not voting for you today.

[columbia]

lol people actually trust each other in these games?!

How many seer or angel role claims are disputed and lead to a kill by the green vig the next night?
Almost never.

[Benny Fitz]

ahh arent you guys (+2girls) forgetting something?

The way I view being a target of a bandwagon:

1. If I'm red, I'll eventually claim to be the Angel.
2. If I'm green, I'll eventually claim my actual role.

Since I won't be doing either, I think you can determine what I am.

columbia already told us he was blue....

And I'm a Knight from King Arthur's court. If I said it, it must be true

whoa! a little early for a role claim, espcially with no heat. you just made my list.

[Malkamaniac]

lol people actually trust each other in these games?!

How many seer or angel role claims are disputed and lead to a kill by the green vig the next night?
Almost never.

I think there needs to be a disclaimer to how many times THG has been the vig and this has happened. I feel that alone is skewing the numbers to your side of the argument.

[canaan]

lynch BennyFitz his presumption to assume columbia is blue based on columbia just saying so makes me think he has the knowledge be more definitive than he should. could be just trusting on face value, but i doubt it.

[Crpl_Klinger]

I don't know about columbia. Kraftster and redwill, as good players, would be targets for anyone. At this point I think I like nan's vote yesterday for thg.
Lynch thg

This was kind of my thought. Despite columbia coming after me, I'm not really sold that he is bad. It just seems like way too obvious of a set up.

That's true... just wanted to have something to base it off of... after watching a few of the last two games I'd say that some of the reds are the worst kind... silent but deadly... I'd be in favor of a strategy of getting rid of the silent players while the seer looks at those who are talking and then we can move forward....

[mac5155]

ahh arent you guys (+2girls) forgetting something?

The way I view being a target of a bandwagon:

1. If I'm red, I'll eventually claim to be the Angel.
2. If I'm green, I'll eventually claim my actual role.

Since I won't be doing either, I think you can determine what I am.

columbia already told us he was blue....

AHHHH yeah duh!

[Malkamaniac]

I don't know about columbia. Kraftster and redwill, as good players, would be targets for anyone. At this point I think I like nan's vote yesterday for thg.
Lynch thg

This was kind of my thought. Despite columbia coming after me, I'm not really sold that he is bad. It just seems like way too obvious of a set up.

That's true... just wanted to have something to base it off of... after watching a few of the last two games I'd say that some of the reds are the worst kind... silent but deadly... I'd be in favor of a strategy of getting rid of the silent players while the seer looks at those who are talking and then we can move forward....

I feel like this is the almost same sentiment each game. Until the last two games where I played "silent" and didn't show up until the last few day phases. Turns out, most of the reds were the ones making communications to steer the group.

I'd imagine there's maybe one silent red, but more often than not I'd imagine you're going to find most reds trying to be as open as possible without revealing anything of value really.

[shafnutz05]

lynch BennyFitz his presumption to assume columbia is blue based on columbia just saying so makes me think he has the knowledge be more definitive than he should. could be just trusting on face value, but i doubt it.

hmm....this logic seems weak. Willie Kool is a seasoned player. I was assuming he was sarcastic when he said columbia already told us he was blue, but I could have been mistaken.

[Malkamaniac]

I'm going to go with lynch PFiDC BennyFitz.

[shafnutz05]

Edit: I meant Benny Fitz in the above post. Sorry.

[Malkamaniac]

Edit: I meant Benny Fitz in the above post. Sorry.

Two comments stuck out, the "he already told us he was blue" and then the add you to the list on Pavel. It's day 2, and that's about all I have to go for. If he's seasoned, then if he's going to go out on a limb like that, I'd assume the emote should be in play no?

I read that as sarcastic but feeling that he meant it a little bit.

[shafnutz05]

I think I am going to stick with LITT....again:

He has one post in the entire thread, and it was a late vote in a bandwagon. NAN managed to survive as a red almost to the end using this same tactic. I feel much more comfortable with this vote than on one of the usual contributors.

[relantel]

lynch BennyFitz his presumption to assume columbia is blue based on columbia just saying so makes me think he has the knowledge be more definitive than he should. could be just trusting on face value, but i doubt it.

hmm....this logic seems weak. Willie Kool is a seasoned player. I was assuming he was sarcastic when he said columbia already told us he was blue, but I could have been mistaken.

canaan reading too much here. Sometimes, if it walks like a duck...

[columbia]

save shad