*** Werewolf XXIII Gameplay Thread ***

[redwill]

Current vote count:

3 - SDD (DocEmrick, shafnutz, newarenanow)
1 - CBear3 (SDD)

7 to lynch.

[columbia]

Have mac or relantel made an appearance?

We sort of got lucky yesterday, but I'm concerned about one of them being red and sitting back watching us pick each other off.

[newarenanow]

We sort of got lucky yesterday, but I'm concerned about one of them being red and sitting back watching us pick each other off.

That's where it's tough. If you get a red on Day 1 or 2, sometimes you don't have a lot to play off of. If you get one too late, you need some luck to win the numbers game.

The best time to get a red is like day 3 or 4 when you can start putting together patterns.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

5 - Kraftster (DocEmrick, shafnutz, MWB, columbia, NAN)

This was the vote count on Krafster before his false seer claim. My guess is one of the above other than MWB is red along with Cbear.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Even this early I think a red would place a vote on a red in order to try to clear themselves in the future.

[columbia]

I'm not ready to vote, but - of the two - I'd be more inclined to go for CBear3.

[CBear3]

If nothing else, his comment about CBear having the second vote on him was just wrong...

3 - SDD (Rylan, Kraftster, CBear3)

Correction: he was right about that....The vote tally, was out of order.

My bad.

Umm that vote tally is right. I was originally suspicious of MWB because with a tied vote (Krafster-2 v. SDD-2) he went after the guy that hadn't played in months. As such I tried to even up with an SDD vote to tie the two.
After Shaf's false role claim last game, I wasn't about to buy into anybody's claims without a little push. In hindsight, shaf could have said, Duh, I'm blue to Krafster's claim, but if he was green he couldn't come out because he'd become a target. Then when MWB came out the reds would have known two greens so the village would be elscrew-ed. It was a tremendously lucky shot for MWB to pick a red the first night, that can't be denied. It just seemed too easy. So I held onto that suspicion until the last. So that was kind of boneheaded on my part.

[Kaizer]

SDD tried to kill me for being a noob, so:

lynch SDD

plus, the stuff you guys said.

[shafnutz05]

I would be theoretically just fine with CBear or SDD, at this point. SDD just seems to be reaching an awful lot, so I'm sticking with him.

MWB, out of curiosity, why did you "see" Doc last night? He was the first person that voted for Kraftster yesterday. Even if he was recruited last night, you wouldn't have known till tonight.

I'm not judging, just wanting to know your train of thought since you are clearly trustworthy.

[newarenanow]

I'm not judging, just wanting to know your train of thought since you are clearly trustworthy.

I don't think we should be discussing this until after the game. I don't want to give the reds anything.

[shafnutz05]

I'm not judging, just wanting to know your train of thought since you are clearly trustworthy.

I don't think we should be discussing this until after the game. I don't want to give the reds anything.

Meh...whatev. MWB can wait to discuss it, just seemed a bit curious to me.

[CBear3]

I'm not judging, just wanting to know your train of thought since you are clearly trustworthy.

I don't think we should be discussing this until after the game. I don't want to give the reds anything.

Or he can PM you...LOL

[MWB]

If nothing else, his comment about CBear having the second vote on him was just wrong...

3 - SDD (Rylan, Kraftster, CBear3)

Correction: he was right about that....The vote tally, was out of order.

My bad.

Umm that vote tally is right. I was originally suspicious of MWB because with a tied vote (Krafster-2 v. SDD-2) he went after the guy that hadn't played in months. As such I tried to even up with an SDD vote to tie the two.
After Shaf's false role claim last game, I wasn't about to buy into anybody's claims without a little push. In hindsight, shaf could have said, Duh, I'm blue to Krafster's claim, but if he was green he couldn't come out because he'd become a target. Then when MWB came out the reds would have known two greens so the village would be elscrew-ed. It was a tremendously lucky shot for MWB to pick a red the first night, that can't be denied. It just seemed too easy. So I held onto that suspicion until the last. So that was kind of boneheaded on my part.

That's an odd reason to be suspicious of me originally. Why not be suspicious of the two people who previously voted for Kraftster, if that's your reasoning? Obviously I was lucky to get Kraftster with my first see; and just as obviously if he came back blue I'd be red (and a complete idiot as well). Obvious statements are suspicious.

[MWB]

I would be theoretically just fine with CBear or SDD, at this point. SDD just seems to be reaching an awful lot, so I'm sticking with him.

MWB, out of curiosity, why did you "see" Doc last night? He was the first person that voted for Kraftster yesterday. Even if he was recruited last night, you wouldn't have known till tonight.

I'm not judging, just wanting to know your train of thought since you are clearly trustworthy.

Because I thought it was very odd for him to immediately vote for Kraftster. I thought he could be doing it as a red thinking that the vote probably wouldn't take off, and even if it did, he'd be off the hook and be trusted the rest of the game. Just seemed very coincidental to me.

[newarenanow]

I would be theoretically just fine with CBear or SDD, at this point. SDD just seems to be reaching an awful lot, so I'm sticking with him.

MWB, out of curiosity, why did you "see" Doc last night? He was the first person that voted for Kraftster yesterday. Even if he was recruited last night, you wouldn't have known till tonight.

I'm not judging, just wanting to know your train of thought since you are clearly trustworthy.

Because I thought it was very odd for him to immediately vote for Kraftster. I thought he could be doing it as a red thinking that the vote probably wouldn't take off, and even if it did, he'd be off the hook and be trusted the rest of the game. Just seemed very coincidental to me.

That has happened the last few games.

[CBear3]

Obvious statements are suspicious.

Obviously, you give me too much credit thinking that I'd see these things as obvious.

[columbia]

5 - Kraftster (DocEmrick, shafnutz, MWB, columbia, NAN)

This was the vote count on Krafster before his false seer claim. My guess is one of the above other than MWB is red along with Cbear.

I'll play along: whom do you suspect the most?

[Rylan]

Yellow Shad.

Being inquisitive of the seer is really weird to me. But if need be, I would get behind a SDD and CBear vote.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

5 - Kraftster (DocEmrick, shafnutz, MWB, columbia, NAN)

This was the vote count on Krafster before his false seer claim. My guess is one of the above other than MWB is red along with Cbear.

I'll play along: whom do you suspect the most?

In this order: Shad, NAN, columbia

Unless Doc has been recruited he has pretty much has to be blue since usually only the alpha red will come back blue when investigated.

[shafnutz05]

Yeah, if I was one of the one or two remaining reds, I would try and discredit the indisputable good seer to draw attention to myself :pop:

[Willie Kool]

Have mac or relantel made an appearance?
We sort of got lucky yesterday, but I'm concerned about one of them being red and sitting back watching us pick each other off.

Mac hasn't posted at all yet, but he's done that at least a few times before as a blue. After MWB merely asked if there was a deadline on the Day 1 vote, rel made his only post -

day 1s are almost always a crapshoot. I might be inclined to a few folks that we haven't heard from yet. Don't think there is any need to rush to a deadline.

No one was rushing anything, MWB just asked if there was a deadline. We haven't heard anything from rel since.

Lynch rel

[MWB]

Cbear is most suspicious to me right now, but I could go with SDD as well.

[columbia]

Cbear is most suspicious to me right now, but I could go with SDD as well.

If one of them is bad, SDD is doing a better job of it.

[shafnutz05]

That's kind of been a pattern for relantel in these games lately. He makes very noncommittal statements most of the time

[CBear3]

Think we're at:

4 - SDD (DocEmrick, shafnutz, newarenanow, Kaizer)
1 - CBear3 (SDD)
1 - shad (Rylan)
1 - rel (WK)

7 to lynch.

No deadline in sight, so there's no rush