Rylan, I think you are grossly underestimating Redwill. He has thrown out several noncommittal, meh votes this game. That is completely unlike him, especially as a blue. I can think of more than one game where he has literally come out of nowhere and sniffed me out when I was red. When he is blue, he is normally much more aggressive, especially in the latter stages of the game.
Just speaking when I play as a red, he scares the crap out of me late in games. The fact that he is a) still around, b) extremely quiet, c) offered nothing of concrete significance tells me he is trying to slip through this last day phase based on previous game rep. I'm not buying it.