YOUR OFFICIAL LGP Top 10 NFL QBs

[IanMoran]

Based on the voting results from previous thread

So many people put "OOO TOP 5 IN ANY ORDER IS (names 5 guys). To deal with this I just did the average of that for your ranking (so in that scenario I'd give 5 guys a ranking of being 3rd. However, if you didn't have 10 guys.. I didn't count your votes at all. I also cut off your ranking when you listed more than 10 guys..

1. Aaron Rodgers 76.5
2. Tom Brady 71.5
3. Drew Brees 65.5
4. Peyton Manning 58.5
5. Eli Manning 41.5
6. Ben Roethlisberger 40.5
7 / 8. Tony Romo and Matthew Stafford both with 22.5
9. Matt Ryan 18.5
10. Phillip Rivers 16.5

Others receiving votes:
Newton (3.5), Vick (1), Flacco (1)

Seems like a pretty good list

[IanMoran]

One interesting note about the voting...

The guys that made every ballot were the top 6 and then Matt Ryan.. Despite finishing 9th overall, everyone put Matt Ryan in there top 10 (obviously usually at the bottom)

[Chefpatrick871]

Ha. Flacco made an lgp account and voted for himself.

[Puffymuffin]

Do people really rate Stafford that high?
Might be me, but I don't see it, then again, I don't see Detroit play every week.

[Froggy]

it's hard to ignore a guy who just threw for like the 4th highest yardage total ever last year

[Puffymuffin]

it's hard to ignore a guy who just threw for like the 4th highest yardage total ever last year

I know, but I think that has more to do with that receiver he has.

[IanMoran]

Tbh.. Stafford was the 1 I had the hardest time ranking either way.

[JoseCuervo]

Do people really rate Stafford that high?

It's pretty hard to rate other QBs better than him, imo.