MWB wrote:But it didn't make sense for redwill to come out when he did.
No, but it worked. No one tried to kill him at night, and the village didn't kill him when they should have either.
But let's change things around. What if we voted redwill out immediately instead of going after canaan? What if nan was killed that night and we never got his info? There's a good chance the reds would have swept.
Up until the village voted out doublem instead of redwill, everything was in line for a good shot at a win. Had we not killed a red at any point prior to that phase, we were risking an all or nothing situation - something that I wanted to avoid.
Really though, doublem kinda screwed us with his killing of known good players, including the angel.