Moderators: Three Stars, dagny, pfim, netwolf
Froggy wrote:staal at 55 is way way way way way way way too high.
Rylan wrote:Though, what is with the Toews love in the world?
Staggy wrote:It's a pretty decent list overall, I think. Making a list like this would be hard as hell so I give him credit there. Two major problems I have with it though. Backstrom (WSH) and Rinne at 94 and 93 respectively. Both should be way higher, IMO
Staggy wrote:Backstrom (WSH) and Rinne at 94 and 93 respectively. Both should be way higher, IMO
Rylan wrote:For the record, it was players you would want for the 2012 playoffs. Rinne has been a less than stellar goalie in the post season.
MRandall25 wrote:I don't think Toews or Giroux deserve to be up there in the Top 5.
Top 10? Maybe. Top 5 is pushing it.
Rylan wrote:For the record, it was players you would want for the 2012 playoffs. Rinne has been a less than stellar goalie in the post season.
Kraftster wrote:These are so hard to do.
Ones that stand out to me more than any others.
Nash at 19... lolololol
Jeff Skinner at 25 - way too early
Tomas Vanek at 39 - maybe where Nash should be with Vanek then being proportionately furthe down the list.
Matt Moulson at 49 - great story, super consistent past three years, but, yeah, no.
Mikko Koivu at 57 - way too high/low (should be top 25)
Jimmy Howard at 68 -- put him on another team and see him fall out of the top 100
Christian Ehrhoff at 72 -- should not be on this list
Loui Eriksson at 77 -- switch him with Vanek
Rinne at 93 -- has he ever watched the Preds?
Backstrom at 94 -- worst on the list, are you kidding, Bucci? (Behind the likes of Mike Fisher, Tomas Plekanec, Joe Pavelski)
André wrote:MRandall25 wrote:I don't think Toews or Giroux deserve to be up there in the Top 5.
Top 10? Maybe. Top 5 is pushing it.
I think Giroux is establishing himself as the third best forward in the world.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests