Moderators: Three Stars, dagny, pfim, netwolf

Letang Is The Truth wrote:FreeCandy44 wrote:Not one Jack Reacher review? Someone on here had to have seen it.
http://bit.ly/UoKjAQ

Dickie Dunn wrote:Eismann wrote:Froggy wrote:Eismann wrote:Starting Prometheus on demand now.
REMOTE PUSH
seriously dude... push the STOP button, or change the channel.
I didn't read any of the spoiler conversations when the movie first came out...Spoiler:.Spoiler:

MRandall25 wrote:Orange whip? Orange whip?
Three orange whips.



FreeCandy44 wrote:Letang Is The Truth wrote:FreeCandy44 wrote:Not one Jack Reacher review? Someone on here had to have seen it.
http://bit.ly/UoKjAQ
LITT come on....your better then this.


tifosi77 wrote:Seek out Jon Spaihts' screenplay online. It's called "Alien: Engineers" and is an order of magnitude better than what Lindelhof 'fixed'. Still needs work, mind you...... but it's the 'green light' draft that Fox read and said "Yes! Let's make this into a movie!" Even in draft form it's so much better than "Prometheus" it's almost enough to make me hit myself in the face with a fry pan. I'd say Spaihts' "Engineers" draft is probably about 90% there.
There are some individual elements of the final film that are better, in my opinion. For example, I really like the idea that "Prometheus" is its own story and that a sequel to this film would not be "Alien"; the original was a self-contained bubble, and isn't really congruous with the larger themes explored by the questions raised in "Engineers"/"Prometheus". But even where improvements in concept were delivered, the final iteration and execution was so poor as to be insulting.


IrishEyes wrote:24 hours of A Christmas Story just started. Heaven!



Eismann wrote:tifosi77 wrote:Seek out Jon Spaihts' screenplay online. It's called "Alien: Engineers" and is an order of magnitude better than what Lindelhof 'fixed'. Still needs work, mind you...... but it's the 'green light' draft that Fox read and said "Yes! Let's make this into a movie!" Even in draft form it's so much better than "Prometheus" it's almost enough to make me hit myself in the face with a fry pan. I'd say Spaihts' "Engineers" draft is probably about 90% there.
There are some individual elements of the final film that are better, in my opinion. For example, I really like the idea that "Prometheus" is its own story and that a sequel to this film would not be "Alien"; the original was a self-contained bubble, and isn't really congruous with the larger themes explored by the questions raised in "Engineers"/"Prometheus". But even where improvements in concept were delivered, the final iteration and execution was so poor as to be insulting.
I pretty much agree with what froggy and tifosi said about this, after reading their original reviews. I think because I was such a fan of the Alien series that I wanted a lot from Prometheus going in that I didn't get.

Rylan wrote:IrishEyes wrote:24 hours of A Christmas Story just started. Heaven!
Yuck



the wicked child wrote:Going to see the Hobbit on Wednesday. /csb

Digitalgypsy66 wrote:I enjoyed This is 40, but it did drag the last 20 minutes or so.


Users browsing this forum: the wicked child and 6 guests