KBone wrote:My first thought is....
Do all of these even exist anymore? Many could be lost to time.

You are correct. I will in all probability never see the end of this project, but I'm going to give it my best shot. Here is the list of sticks I already have. Try finding some of these today:
Penguin player related sticks:
Left handed:
Ramzi Abid: CCM
Russ Anderson: Canadien
Mathew Barnaby: Innovative
Kris Beech: CCM
Neil Belland: Sher Wood
Josef Beranek: Sher Wood x3, CCM, Hespeller
Mark Bergevin: Koho
Stefan Bergkvist: Branches
Rick Berry: Easton
Wayne Bianchin: Sher Wood
Paul Bissonnette: Reebok
Doug Bodger: Sher Wood
Joel Bouchard: Easton
Chris Bourque: Reebok
Phil Bourque: Sher Wood
Pat Boutette: Victoriaville
Andy Brickley: Sher Wood
Rob Brown: Titan
Kelly Buchberger: Easton
Mike Bullard: Chimo, Victoriaville
Dave Burrows: Wilson, Sher Wood
Sven Butenschon: Victoriaville x2, Louisville response, CCM
Dan Bylsma: Bauer
Eric Cairns: Victoriaville
Dave Capuano: Sher Wood
Randy Carlyle: Louisville
John Chabot: Sher Wood
Todd Charlesworth: Sher Wood
Erik Christensen: Reebok
Jeff Christian: Sher Wood
Marc Chorney: Koho
Paul Coffey: Sher Wood
Mike Comrie: Easton
Chris Conner: Reebok
Matt Cooke: Reebok
Ryan Craig: Reebok
Cory Cross: Koho
Greg Crozier: Sher Wood
Randy Cunneyworth: Sher Wood x2
Chris Dahlquist: Koho
Alexander Daigle: Sher Wood
J.J. Daigneault: Koho, Sher Wood x2
Jeff Daniels: Koho x2
Larry De Palma: Canadien
Bobby Dollas: Itech x3
Robert Dome: Koho x2
Pascal Dupuis: Bauer Supreme ONE95
Steve Dykstra: Koho x2
Joe Dziedzic: Koho
Mark Eaton: TPS
Shane Endicott: CCM
Bob Errey: Titan x2
Rico Fata: Easton Synergy
Ruslan Fedotenko: Mission
Andrew Ference: Koho
Ron Flockhart: Sher Wood
Dan Focht: Branches
Corey Foster: Sher Wood
Ron Francis: Louisville
Maxim Galanov: Sher Wood x3
Stan Gilbertson: Koho
Randy Gilhen: Sher Wood
Hal Gill: Sher Wood
Tuomas Gronman: Bauer x3
Scott Gruhl: Sher Wood
Dave Hannan: Sher Wood x2
Greg Hawgood: Sher Wood
Alex Hicks: Bauer
Todd Hlushko: Sher Wood x2
Jiri Hrdina: Koho
Mike Hudson: Hespeller, Sher Wood
Jaromir Jagr: Koho
Dustin Jeffrey: Reebok
Grant Jennings: Koho
Greg Johnson: Koho
Jim Johnson: Victoriaville x2
Mark Johnson: Canadien
Hans Jonsson: CCM x4
Mark Kachowski: Koho, Sher Wood
Darius Kasparaitis: Koho
Bob Kelly: Sher Wood
Chris Kontos: Chimo
Alexei Kovalev: Itech
Frantisek Kucera: Sher Wood
Chris Kuntz: Easton Synergy x2
Jim Kyte: Koho x2
Joel Kwiatkowski: Mission
Dan Lacouture: Koho Torpedo
Mitch Lamoureux: Sher Wood
Janne Laukkanen: Bauer x3
Kevin LaVallee: Koho
Patrick Lebeau: Sher Wood, Victoriaville
John LeClair: Sher Wood
Alain Lemieux: Titan
Francois Leroux: Koho x2
Willy Lindstrom: Sher Wood
Troy Loney: Sher Wood
Steve Macintyre: CCM
Evgeni Malkin: Warrior
Greg Malone: Sherwood x2
Ryan Malone: Easton S17
Greg Malone: Sher Wood
Paul Martin: TPS Response
Bryan Maxwell: Sher Wood
Shaun McEachern: Easton
Jay McKee: Easton
Jim McKenzie: Branches
Dave Mcllwain: Louisville
Josef Melichar: Easton
Dave Michayluk: Titan
Kip Miller: Sher Wood x5, Louisville
Carl Mokosak: Sher Wood
Dominic Moore: Easton Synergy
Alexei Morozov: Easton x2, Nike x2
Craig Muni: Sher Wood
Matt Murley: Sher Wood
Markus Naslund: Titan
Petr Nedved: Titan x2
Ville Nieminen: Sher Wood x2
Jeff Norton: Bauer
Ed Olczyk: Titan
Krzysztof Oliwa: Nike, Victoriaville
Tom O'Reagan: Sher Wood
Brooks Orpik: Bauer
Jim Paek: Koho
Ziggy Palffy: Victoriaville
Bob Paradise: Koho
Toby Petersen: Koho x2
Alex Picard: Bauer
Dominic Pittis: Koho
Greg Polis: Koho
Peter Popovic: Sher Wood x3, Montreal
Ken Priestlay: Canadien
Wayne Primmeau: Sher Wood
Sean Pronger: Louisville TPS
Dan Quinn: Titan
Mike Ramsey: Canadien
Mark Recchi: Koho
Todd Reirden: Sher Wood
Janne Rita: Nike
Gordie Roberts: Canadien
Luc Robitaille: Innovative
Randy Robitaille: Christian
Andre Roy: CCM
Duane Rupp: Sher Wood
Terry Ruskowski: Sher Wood
Jarkko Ruutu: TPS
Phil Samuelsson: Reebok
Ulf Samuelsson: Victoriaville
Tomas Sandstrom: Sher Wood
Miroslav Satan: Easton
Ron Schock: Northland
Rod Scuderri: Easton
Greg Sheppard: Koho
Jon Sim: Easton
Roman Simicek: Koho
Charlie Simmer: Titan
Reid Simpson: Easton
Ville Siren: Montreal
Michael Sivek: CCM
Martin Skoula: Easton
John Slaney: Koho x2
Jiri Slegr: Louisville x2, Koho
Jordan Staal: Bauer Vapor
Kevin Stevens: Victoriaville, Louisville, Koho
Alek Stojanov: Easton
Brian Strait: Reebok
Martin Straka: Koho x2,
Thomas Surovy: CCM
Darryl Sydor: Sher Wood
Jeff Taffe: Easton
Peter Taglianetti: Koho, Louisville x2
Maxime Talbot: Warrior
Chris Tamer: Bauer
Tony Tanti: Sher Wood
Mark Taylor: Sher Wood
Dave Tippett: Canadien, Easton
German Titov: Sher Wood
Tim Tookey: Canadien
Bryan Trottier: Victoriaville
Wayne Van Dorp: Sher Wood
Vladamir Vujtek: Sher Wood
Noah Welch: Sher Wood
Chris Wells: Koho
Brad Werenka: Christian x2, CCM
Ryan Whitney: Easton Synergy
Mike Wilson: CCM
Jason Wooley: Hespeller
Harry York: Itech
Warren Young: Canadien
Zarly Zalapski: Koho x2, Titan
256 Left handed total
Right handed:
Greg Andrusak: Sher Wood
Syl Apps: Sher Wood
Colby Armstrong: Reebok
Aaron Asham: Easton
Wayne Babych: Sher Wood
Stu Barnes: Victoriaville
Nolan Baumgartner
Paul Baxter: Koho
Drake Berehowsky: Christian
Nick Beverley: Victoriaville
Mike Blaisdell: Canadien
Eric Bogunecki: Sher Wood
Dennis Bonvie: Victoriaville x3, Koho
Philippe Boucher: Koho
Bob Boughner: Inovative
Tim Brent: CCM
Doug Brown: Sher Wood
Greg Brown: Sher Wood x2
Rod Buskas: Sher Wood
Jock Callander: Koho x2
Jay Caufield: Koho
Blair Chapman: Koho
Tom Chorske: Sher Wood
Bruce Crowder: Sher Wood
John Cullen: Koho x2
Gilbert Delorme: Chimo x2
Ab Demarco: Victoriaville
Gord Dineen: Sher Wood x2
Shean Donovan: Easton
Ron Duguay: Victoriaville
Mike Eastwood: Sher Wood
Derryk Engelland: Easton
Bryan Erickson: Christian
Pat Falloon: Sher Wood
Peter Ferraro: Victoriaville
Dan Frawley: Sher Wood
Perry Ganchar: Chimo
Lee Giffin: Louisville
Eric Godard: Bauer
Tony Granato: Easton, Chimo
Bill Guerin: Easton
Adam Hall: Bauer Vapor
Kevin Hatcher: Koho x3, Bauer
Randy Hillier: Sher Wood
Brian Holzinger: Easton
Jan Hrdina: Koho x2
Richard Jackman: TPS
Chris Joseph: Branches, Sher Wood x2
Rick Kehoe: Sher Wood x2
Tom Kostopoulos: Koho x2
Milan Kraft: Easton
Robert Lang: Koho
Georges Laraque: Reebok
Pierre Larouche: Koho
Jamie Leach: Sher Wood x2, Koho
Steve Leach: Victoriaville
Peter Lee: Sher Wood
Mario Lemieux: Koho, Titan
Moe Mantha: Sher Wood, Chimo
Kevin McCarthy: Canadien
Al McDonough: Victoriaville
Eric Meloche: CCM
Kevin Miller: Easton
Dmitri Mironov: Montreal
Ian Moran: Franklin
Joe Mullen: Canadien
Larry Murphy: CCM
Glen Murray: Sher Wood,Koho x2
Troy Murray: Koho
Mike Needham: Canadien x2
Lyle Odelein: Sher Wood
Freddy Olausson: Louisville
Michel Ouellet: Sher Wood, CCM
Wilf Paiement: Koho
Richard Park: Koho
Ed Patterson: Branches, Bauer
Barry Pederson: Sher Wood
Jamie Pushor: Easton x2
Stephane Richer: Sher Wood x3, chimo
Michal Rozsival: Koho w/easton blade
Kjel Sammuelsson: Titan
Ryan Savoia: Sher Wood
Norm Schmidt: Koho
Doug Shedden: Sher Wood
Craig Simpson: Sher Wood
Bryan Smilonski: Koho
Carl Sneep: Reebok
Paul Stanton: Sher Wood
Mike Stapleton: Koho, Canadien
Blaine Stoughton: Sher Wood
Rich Sutter: Easton
Bill Thomas: Easton
Billy Tibbetts: Sher Wood
Rick Tocchet: CCM, Koho
Ryan VandenBussche: Sher Wood
Joe Vitale: Easton
Bryan Watson: Koho
Steve Webb: Branches
Neil Wilkinson: Victoriaville, Koho
Tyler Wright: Koho x4
Scott Young: Canadien
Richard Zemlak: Sher Wood
Mike Zigomanis: Easton
Sergei Zubov: Victoriaville, Easton
141 Right handed total
Goalie Sticks:
J.S. Aubin: Koho x3, Sher Wood x2, Cooper, Branches
Tom Barrasso: Heaton, Sher Wood
Martin Brochu: Sher Wood
Sebastien Caron: Bauer
Alain Chevriere: Victoriaville
Andy Chiodo: CCM
Ty Conklin: TPS
John Curry: Sher Wood
Philippe Derouville: Sher Wood
Michel Dion: Victoriaville, CCM
Rob Dopson: Sher Wood, Louisville
Gary Edwards: Sher Wood
M.A. Fleury: Koho "First stick used in first camp"
Mathieu Garon: Reebok
Johan Hedberg: Sher Wood x2
Dana Heinze: Sher Wood x3
Denis Heron: Cooper
Robert Holland: Victoriaville
Gary Inness: Sher Wood
Brent Johnson: Bauer
Patrick Lalime Koho
Gordie Laxton: Northland
Gillies Meloche: Sher Wood
Greg Millen: Chimo
Rich Parrent: Sher Wood
Frank Pieterangelo: Sher Wood
Pat Riggin: Wally
Roberto Romano: Sher Wood
Jim Rutherford: Northland
Danny Sabourin: Sher Wood x5
Peter Skudra: Heaton x3
Garth Snow: CCM
Rick Tabaracci: Christian, Louisville
Jocelyn Thibault: Sher Wood
Brad Thiessen: Bauer
Ron Tugnutt: Victoriaville
Ken Wregget: Cooper x2, Bauer x2
Wendell Young: Sher Wood x2
61 Goalie Total
Grand total of 458 Penguin sticks.