Moderators: Three Stars, dagny, pfim, netwolf
DelPen wrote:I'd give it to Anderson even over Crosby. The award should go to most valuable to his team. There are so many good players on this team it's hard to pick whop is the MOST valuable. The only reason the Sens are in the playoff piscture at all is because of him especially after Karlson went down.
Giving it to Ovechkin would be a **** joke. He played **** hockey until April and giving it to him would be an embarrassment.
IanMoran wrote:I really think voters don't go by the criteria provided to them.
Hart trophy
"Player judged most valuable to his team"
Lindsay trophy
"Most outstanding player in the regular season."
Best on those criteria the Hart should go to Ovy and the Lindsay to Crosby.
Based on how voters really vote historically, the Hart should go to Crosby
nexguy66 wrote:IanMoran wrote:I really think voters don't go by the criteria provided to them.
Hart trophy
"Player judged most valuable to his team"
Lindsay trophy
"Most outstanding player in the regular season."
Best on those criteria the Hart should go to Ovy and the Lindsay to Crosby.
Based on how voters really vote historically, the Hart should go to Crosby
I think based on those criteria the Hart should always go to a goalie. Bobrovsky is statistically more important than any skater. The top several most valuable players are all goalies.
DelPen wrote:meow wrote:In the purest sense of the language, Kovalchuk should win the Hart.
But the Devils sucked when he was in and Brodeur was out too. The Devils just suck.
thepittman wrote:AO stepped up scoring, brought his team back from missing the playoffs, and now they lead their division. Makes a pretty good case.
DelPen wrote:nexguy66 wrote:IanMoran wrote:I really think voters don't go by the criteria provided to them.
Hart trophy
"Player judged most valuable to his team"
Lindsay trophy
"Most outstanding player in the regular season."
Best on those criteria the Hart should go to Ovy and the Lindsay to Crosby.
Based on how voters really vote historically, the Hart should go to Crosby
I think based on those criteria the Hart should always go to a goalie. Bobrovsky is statistically more important than any skater. The top several most valuable players are all goalies.
but the BJ's are out of the playoff picture (barely) right now and they have the 9th most goals against in the West. Is he really that important? He makes a horrible team average? I don't think so.
DelPen wrote:MRandall25 wrote:That stat doesn't make sense when you look at Bob's stats and see he's 2nd in SV% and 6th in the league in GAA
so i guess Mason sucked that bad?
Froggy wrote:Anyone saying anybody but Crosby is over thinking it.
Froggy wrote:Anyone saying anybody but Crosby is over thinking it.
newarenanow wrote:Froggy wrote:Anyone saying anybody but Crosby is over thinking it.
I don't think so. I think writers will punish Crosby for getting injured, and reward AO for being hot at the end of the season when his tear is fresh in everyones minds.
newarenanow wrote:Froggy wrote:Anyone saying anybody but Crosby is over thinking it.
I don't think so. I think writers will punish Crosby for getting injured, and reward AO for being hot at the end of the season when his tear is fresh in everyones minds.
Users browsing this forum: FallenHero96, Faubert5 and 29 guests