Holiday Wars - After Party

[Kicksave]

The game was full of panic for the first half of the game, however things started getting interesting once it was figured out there was two mafia families.

Some notes on the roles...
- I didn't want to give each mafia the same powers so one had the doctor and the other had the investigator.
- We gave each mafia a mason and they were going to talk to one another. What we told them was that the other person doesn't know the other's mafia afiliation. I'm curious to see how this played out.
- I gave the town the back-up roles to try and even the playing field a bit more. I was toying with the idea of having an independant serial killer and calling him the Athiest but with the two mafias, I figured there was enough confusion.

The Roles
The Mafias
Scrooge Godfather - Charlie Brown (Juice)
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper)
Scrooge Mafia Mason - Ralphie (MWB)
Scrooge Mafia Member - Frank Cross (npv708)
Grinch Godfather - Louis Winthorpe (Troy Loney)
Grinch Mafia Doctor - Frosty (JoseCuervo)
Grinch Mafia Mason - Cousin Eddy (sdm5055)
Grinch Mafia Member - Scott Farkas (IrishEyes)

The Town
Town Investigator - Snow Miser (Malkamaniac)
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity)
Jack Of All Trades - Kevin McCallister (thehockeyguru)
Town Vigilante - Mary, the Underwear Cashier (newarenanow)
Town Deputy - Yukon Cornelius (Letang is the Truth)
Town Nurse - Scott Calvin (mac5155)
Willie/Bad Santa (slappybrown)
Buddy (tfrizz)
Clark Griswold (shafnutz05)
George Bailey (redwill)
Tiny Tim (bhaw)
Howard Langston (jaysmiter)
Roboto Santa (the wicked child)
Christmas Story Leg Lamp (Corvidae)
Sally (dagny)
Heat Miser (canaan)
Grinch (beerman)
Professor Hinkle (crayz)
The Abominable Snowman (Zarovich)
Blue Christmas Girl (wallflower)
Jesus Christ - (PensFaninDC)
Golden Echo Harmonica(JarkkoVision)

[Kicksave]

How the nights played out...

NIGHT 1
Scrooge Godfather - Charlie Brown (Juice) - KILLS canaan
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES bhaw
Grinch Godfather - Louis Winthorpe (Troy Loney) - NO KILL TONIGHT
Grinch Mafia Doctor - Frosty (JoseCuervo) - PROTECTS SELF
Town Investigator - Snow Miser (Malkamaniac) - INVESTIGATES slappybrown
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - SAVES Juice
Jack Of All Trades - Kevin McCallister (thehockeyguru) - NO ACTION
Town Vigilante - Mary, the Underwear Cashier (newarenanow) - NO ACTION

DAY 1
Zarovich - Unwrapped by Town

NIGHT 2
Scrooge Godfather - Charlie Brown (Juice) - NO KILL TONIGHT
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES Newarenanow
Grinch Godfather - Louis Winthorpe (Troy Loney) - KILLS shafnutz05
Grinch Mafia Doctor - Frosty (JoseCuervo) - SAVES sdm5055
Town Investigator - Snow Miser (Malkamaniac) - INVESTIGATES PensFaninDC
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - SAVES dagny
Jack Of All Trades - Kevin McCallister (thehockeyguru) - INVESTIGATES Crayz
Town Vigilante - Mary, the Underwear Cashier (newarenanow) - SHOOTS Jaysmiter

DAY 2
redwill - Unwrapped by Town

NIGHT 3
Scrooge Godfather - Charlie Brown (Juice) - KILLS newarenanow
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES Malkamaniac
Grinch Godfather - Louis Winthorpe (Troy Loney) - NO KILL TONIGHT
Grinch Mafia Doctor - Frosty (JoseCuervo) - PROTECTS Troy Loney
Town Investigator - Snow Miser (Malkamaniac) - INVESTIGATES count2infinity
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - SAVES Irisheyes
Jack Of All Trades - Kevin McCallister (thehockeyguru) -KILLS Wallflower
Town Vigilante - Mary, the Underwear Cashier (newarenanow) - NO ACTION

DAY 3
thehockeyguru - Unwrapped by Town

NIGHT 4
Scrooge Godfather - Charlie Brown (Juice) - NO KILL TONIGHT
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES the wicked child
Grinch Godfather - Louis Winthorpe (Troy Loney) - KILLS Juice
Grinch Mafia Doctor - Frosty (JoseCuervo) - PROTECTS JoseCuervo
Town Investigator - Snow Miser (Malkamaniac) - INVESTIGATES Troy Loney
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - PROTECTS count2infinity


DAY 4
Letang is the Truth - Unwrapped by Town

NIGHT 5
Frank Cross (npv708) - Becomes new Scrooge Mafia Godfather
Scrooge Godfather - Frank Cross (npv708) - KILLS Malkamaniac
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES Corvidae
Grinch Godfather - Louis Winthorpe (Troy Loney) - NO KILL TONIGHT
Grinch Mafia Doctor - Frosty (JoseCuervo) - PROTECTS TroyLoney
Town Investigator - Snow Miser (Malkamaniac) - INVESTIGATES JoseCuervo
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - PROTECTS npv708

DAY 5
dagny - Unwrapped by Town

NIGHT 6
Scrooge Godfather - Frank Cross (npv708) - NO KILL TONIGHT
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES tfrizz
Grinch Godfather - Louis Winthorpe (Troy Loney) - KILLS tfrizz
Grinch Mafia Doctor - Frosty (JoseCuervo) - PROTECTS JoseCuervo
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - PROTECTS count2infinity

DAY 6
Troy Loney - Unwrapped by Town

NIGHT 7
JoseCuervo - Becomes new Scrooge Mafia Godfather
Scrooge Godfather - Frank Cross (npv708) - KILLS beerman
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES JoseCuervo
Grinch Godfather - JoseCuervo - NO KILL TONIGHT
Grinch Mafia Doctor - Frosty (JoseCuervo) - PROTECTS IrishEyes
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - PROTECTS slappybrown

DAY 7
JoseCuervo - Unwrapped by Town

NIGHT 8
IrishEyes - Becomes new Scrooge Mafia Godfather
Scrooge Godfather - Frank Cross (npv708) - NO KILL TONIGHT
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES mac5155
Grinch Godfather - Scott Farkas (IrishEyes) - KILLS slappybrown
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - PROTECTS count2infinity

DAY 8
JarkkoVision - Unwrapped by Town

NIGHT 9
Scrooge Godfather - Frank Cross (npv708) - KILLS PensFaninDC
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES crayz
Grinch Godfather - Scott Farkas (IrishEyes) - NO KILL TONIGHT
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - PROTECTS crayz

DAY 9
sdm5055 - Unwrapped by Town

NIGHT 10
Scrooge Godfather - Frank Cross (npv708) - NO KILL TONIGHT
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES IrishEyes
Grinch Godfather - Scott Farkas (IrishEyes) - KILLS mac5155
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - PROTECTS count2infinity

DAY 10
IrishEyes - Unwrapped by Town

NIGHT 11
Scrooge Godfather - Frank Cross (npv708) - KILLS crayz
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES count2infinity
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - PROTECTS npv707

DAY 11
bhaw - Unwrapped by Town

[slappybrown]

at THG. two straight games of epic fail

[Malkamaniac]

I had Troy and Jose back to back nights, I was killed the night I inspected Jose. I was so ready to come out guns blazing.

[npv708]

Hey C2I,

Thanks for the protection.

Signed,
Mafia Godfather NPV...

[npv708]

I had Troy and Jose back to back nights, I was killed the night I inspected Jose. I was so ready to come out guns blazing.

Don't worry, we took them out for you.

lol.

[Malkamaniac]

I had Troy and Jose back to back nights, I was killed the night I inspected Jose. I was so ready to come out guns blazing.

Don't worry, we took them out for you.

lol.

Why did you kill me. Did I give off an obvious role or was it just to get me out?

[npv708]

I had Troy and Jose back to back nights, I was killed the night I inspected Jose. I was so ready to come out guns blazing.

Don't worry, we took them out for you.

lol.

Why did you kill me. Did I give off an obvious role or was it just to get me out?

cup keeper investigated you. We knew your powers and didn't want you around because of that. You were a threat to us...so you slept with the fishes.

[MWB]

FWIW, sdm and I really didn't talk to each other much at all. When we found out malka was the investigator I tried to get sdm's thoughts on him to see if we could push a vote his way. He didn't respond and we didn't talk again.

[mac5155]

Crayz?! Really THG lol u wanna even the playing field investigate someone good haha wow

[mac5155]

Night 4: why did Scrooge investigate Scrooge?

[Malkamaniac]

cup keeper investigated you. We knew your powers and didn't want you around because of that. You were a threat to us...so you slept with the fishes.

Ah ok, from a good rp stand point did I give anything away regarding my status? First time doing it and I wanted to be a harder player to read.

[mac5155]

Night 7 I mean

[npv708]

Night 7 I mean

NIGHT 7
JoseCuervo - Becomes new Scrooge Mafia Godfather
Scrooge Godfather - Frank Cross (npv708) - KILLS beerman
Scrooge Mafia Cop - Bob Cratchit (cupkeeper) - INVESTIGATES JoseCuervo
Grinch Godfather - JoseCuervo - NO KILL TONIGHT
Grinch Mafia Doctor - Frosty (JoseCuervo) - PROTECTS IrishEyes
Town Docotor - Mr. Hankey, The Christmas Poo (count2infinity) - PROTECTS slappybrown

JC was Grinch.

[tfrizz]

Night 7 I mean

They didn't... cup keeper (Scrooge) investigated JoseCuervo (Grinch)

[slappybrown]

I had Troy and Jose back to back nights, I was killed the night I inspected Jose. I was so ready to come out guns blazing.

Don't worry, we took them out for you.

lol.

Why did you kill me. Did I give off an obvious role or was it just to get me out?

I knew you were the investigator because at one point you said "I think you are fine, I dont want to argue" and I figurd youd investigated me.

[mac5155]

Night 7 I mean

They didn't... cup keeper (Scrooge) investigated JoseCuervo (Grinch)

it says JC became new Scrooge godfather.. I assume that's a typo

[npv708]

Night 7 I mean

They didn't... cup keeper (Scrooge) investigated JoseCuervo (Grinch)

it says JC became new Scrooge godfather.. I assume that's a typo

Ya, its a typo. I was the Scrooge godfather after Juice was killed. JC became the Grinch godfather.

[Malkamaniac]

Slappy said:

I knew you were the investigator because at one point you said "I think you are fine, I dont want to argue" and I figurd youd investigated me.

Yea, I didn't want to get caught up in whatever was going on at the moment and left it at that. Most people say that all the time and no one thinks of it so I did as well. Turns out, I died that night phase I believe anyways.

I also made the mention of Troy that day phase, and Corvi jumped on talking about how saying someone being overly defensive means nothing. So I backed off and we killed a good RP I believe.

[slappybrown]

Slappy said:

I knew you were the investigator because at one point you said "I think you are fine, I dont want to argue" and I figurd youd investigated me.

Yea, I didn't want to get caught up in whatever was going on at the moment and left it at that. Most people say that all the time and no one thinks of it so I did as well. Turns out, I died that night phase I believe anyways.

I also made the mention of Troy that day phase, and Corvi jumped on talking about how saying someone being overly defensive means nothing. So I backed off and we killed a good RP I believe.

Yea your Troy quote was huge, even though you were dead,when I reposted it, Troy came out with his silly story. Otherwise, this game would have been a romp for the mafias.

[wallflower]

Oh, just so everyone knows now, in future games I am always going after thehockeyguru. Always.

And the wicked child played an excellent game.

[npv708]

Yea your Troy quote was huge, even though you were dead,when I reposted it, Troy came out with his silly story. Otherwise, this game would have been a romp for the mafias.

It still was, for the Scrooge family at least...

[slappybrown]

Yea your Troy quote was huge, even though you were dead,when I reposted it, Troy came out with his silly story. Otherwise, this game would have been a romp for the mafias.

It still was, for the Scrooge family at least...

Yea the Troy vote and the next couple rounds were the only time I felt the village was getting anywhere is what I meant.

[thehockeyguru]

Crayz?! Really THG lol u wanna even the playing field investigate someone good haha wow

THe guy was on me game 1 from the start and game two rolls around and its the same thing. I had to make sure he was good.

[thehockeyguru]

at THG. two straight games of epic fail

If there was a better chance that I'd make it through the first few days I wouldn't have used my powers blindly. What I find amazing is how you can eliminate a Good Role player on the 3rd day, when I did everything possible to not be suspicious.