I'm not sure if there's really anything we can get from the dagny vote. Mikeenike started it, and was bad.... so maybe it was a concerted effort by the baddies to get her out. However, things went pretty quickly and it's hard to pick out where the vote really took off, because let's be honest, people like to vote for her. Badhands did put in the last vote, so there's possibly something there. Other than that, I'll I've got is the weak Kicksave tells. Anyone else have any thoughts?
I'm not sure if there's really anything we can get from the dagny vote. Mikeenike started it, and was bad.... so maybe it was a concerted effort by the baddies to get her out. However, things went pretty quickly and it's hard to pick out where the vote really took off, because let's be honest, people like to vote for her. Badhands did put in the last vote, so there's possibly something there. Other than that, I'll I've got is the weak Kicksave tells. Anyone else have any thoughts?
shank beerman
Kinda already posted some on kicksave. I am shanking beerman because he didn't smuggle any beer in.
Meh, you can shank me if you want but it won't be a good idea. I'll go with BadHands and get that going. Put the final nail in dagny's coffin even after she came out as a good RPer.
Well, dagny posted that she was green at 12:18. At 12:22 badhands put in her vote. Is that enough of a gap between posts to say that she voted knowing that dagny was green?
I think it's easily enough time for a careful poster (I dunno if that include BadHands). However, I would find it hard to believe that a baddie would do that knowingly. Too obvious. UNLESS it was the killing vote on a green RP (which of course it was). Then I think they might take the chance.
What do you think about it?
It's hard to say. Like you said, a careful poster would certainly not do that
But you ARE a careful poster. Yet you attempted to save dagny seven minutes after Azkar said it was too late. That's opposed to BadHands' four minute lapse. A knowingly pointless attempt to distance yourself from the dagny vote?
Your posts on Day, er, Night 1 struck me as odd to start with. (Don't bother to ask me why -- I can't explain it). Combine that with the late, late attempt to save dagny and it's worth a Night 2 vote, IMO.
But you ARE a careful poster. Yet you attempted to save dagny seven minutes after Azkar said it was too late. That's opposed to BadHands' four minute lapse. A knowingly pointless attempt to distance yourself from the dagny vote?
Your posts on Day, er, Night 1 struck me as odd to start with. (Don't bother to ask me why -- I can't explain it). Combine that with the late, late attempt to save dagny and it's worth a Night 2 vote, IMO.
shank MWB
You're right, I am a careful poster. However, I had been gone for a little bit and was catching up. As soon as I saw dagny's "I'm green" I put in a reply immediately to unshank, because I knew the vote was close. I didn't want to waste time reading through the remaining votes.
You guys really need to quit doing the same things over and over.
I'm green.
Just like last game?
Well, there is one person who knew for sure that dagny said she was green, yet didn't change his vote.
O really? How did i know for "sure" that dagny was green?? She was red last game and pulled the same thing. This seems
like a lousy way to deflect
attention
Voting to end a green after they out themselves is shady. If we don't do this now, we're just going to come back to it everyday and discuss the merits of voting her off.
this game took off on day 1, only seven pages but a bunch of dead people..
rather easy to read back through.
the Dagny vote doesnt give us a lot I dont think. It was started by a baddie so I doubt another bad guy votes 3rd, and the bandwagon was almost all rolled up when she was finally able to post so the fact that people were late releasing her or never did doesnt really show me anything.
I need to keep reading through before I make any shanks
Well, there is one person who knew for sure that dagny said she was green, yet didn't change his vote.
O really? How did i know for "sure" that dagny was green?? She was red last game and pulled the same thing. This seems
like a lousy way to deflect
attention
shank mwb
color pls on phone
Reread my post. I didn't say you knew for "sure" that dagny was green. I said you knew that she said she was green. I only mentioned it because there is some question as to whether or not badhands knew that for sure.