Mad Scientist Warz Game Thread

[TheHammer24]

Lynch Mac

[relantel]

2 - mac (redwill, hammer)
2 - gaucho (benny, shaf)
1 - hammer (mac)

6 needed.

[mac5155]

Everyone has evidence of it not being them except Willie or Mac -- either by way of TEIB seeing them or by voting for Rylan. Someone claims Gaucho is clear, but I don't know where that happened.

As I stated, I genuinely believe Willie is blue based on his incessant digging to figure out why I'm Red. Even after I stated this, he still said he thought I might be a recruited Red. These are not baddie comments, IMO. If we assume we have one bad and one recruit, I say we go after Mac.

When were you cleared? Pre-recruit. Perfect candidate for recruit. Started playing right around that time. Just all adds up IMO.

[redwill]

MWB, you had a pretty quick switch of suspicion there from TheHammer to mac. Not accusing, just observing.

[TheHammer24]

Hammer, you were cleared night one, so could have been a recruit. However, I'd be surprised if you were recruited. Shaf was also cleared night one and could be the recruit. Mac is probably a decent vote.

Yeah I completely agree. The write up seems pretty heavily to indicate that the recruit happened on night 5 though.

[mac5155]

Hammer, you were cleared night one, so could have been a recruit. However, I'd be surprised if you were recruited. Shaf was also cleared night one and could be the recruit. Mac is probably a decent vote.

uhhh

[mac5155]

you know who we need to clear this up: malkamaniac. owait.

[Malkamaniac]

you know who we need to clear this up: malkamaniac. owait.

wat

[TheHammer24]

Everyone has evidence of it not being them except Willie or Mac -- either by way of TEIB seeing them or by voting for Rylan. Someone claims Gaucho is clear, but I don't know where that happened.

As I stated, I genuinely believe Willie is blue based on his incessant digging to figure out why I'm Red. Even after I stated this, he still said he thought I might be a recruited Red. These are not baddie comments, IMO. If we assume we have one bad and one recruit, I say we go after Mac.

When were you cleared? Pre-recruit. Perfect candidate for recruit. Started playing right around that time. Just all adds up IMO.

I have many posts before night 5. Many of them were just quoted by you. The recruit could have happened before, but it's not consistent with the story line.

[Benny Fitz]

mac it's a shame you dont play with a spine more often. im actually at a loss for how to read you right now.

[mac5155]

you know who we need to clear this up: malkamaniac. owait.

wat

so you are still trolling the thread

[mac5155]

mac it's a shame you dont play with a spine more often. im actually at a loss for how to read you right now.

thanks, i guess

[Malkamaniac]

you know who we need to clear this up: malkamaniac. owait.

wat

so you are still trolling the thread

Um, what?

[mac5155]

you had 2 posts since thursday.

[TheHammer24]

There's 10 people left. 4 have been identified as blue at one point (hammer, shaf, redwill, malka (guaranteed)) 2 seem unlikely to be red (Benny and MWB for their votes on Rylan). 3 are unknown (Gauch, Mac, Willie).

It makes no sense to go after the recruit before the 3 unknown. There is a 1/3 chance will get a red. If we go after the recruit there is a 1/5 chance of getting red.

[Malkamaniac]

you had 2 posts since thursday.

Sorry for being away from the computer and busy at work.

lynch mac5155

[TheHammer24]

Well, unless you're Mac, I guess. He's the only vote so far that doesn't subscribe to this probability.

[mac5155]

you had 2 posts since thursday.

Sorry for being away from the computer and busy at work.

lynch mac5155

did I hurt your feelings? I sorry

[Malkamaniac]

you had 2 posts since thursday.

Sorry for being away from the computer and busy at work.

lynch mac5155

did I hurt your feelings? I sorry

You criticize me for not posting, and then you criticize for voting. What/who would you like me to vote for?

[MWB]

MWB, you had a pretty quick switch of suspicion there from TheHammer to mac. Not accusing, just observing.

I just really don't know what to make of Hammer. He was cleared night one, so he would have to be the recruit. I think it's doubtful that the reds would pick him as a recruit, just because he's fairly new. However, some of his posts make him seem extremely red. Makes my head spin.

Mac hasn't had much going on and is also tough to read, so I think he's a possible candidate, as others have said.

Need to read more on WK to form an opinion.

Gaucho, as I said before, I thought was the seer. Then figured he might have some role after teib came out. However, he brought up Rylan's name early so not sure if he would take that risk.

Shaf, cleared early, could be recruit. He also voted early for IE, meaning the reds may have thought it would be good to recruit someone who had voted for one of them.

/randomthoughts

[TheHammer24]

If we go Mac, Gaucho, WK in any order then we're guaranteed to get the non-recruit in three days, probably sooner.

Day 8 - miss the original red
Night 8 - kill a blue

Day 9 - miss the original red
Night 9 - kill the blue

Day 10 - get the original red
Night 10 - kill a blue

Worst case scenario it would be 3 villagers to 1 recruit at that point. And that is worst case scenario guessing at random between Mac, Gaucho, and WK.

Since we feel so strongly on Mac and Gaucho, it looks like we'd be looking at:

7 - 1 or 5 - 1

[TheHammer24]

Yikes, I guess 3-1 and 5-1 aren't as good as I thought.

Regardless, probability of 1/3 or 1/5 -- we should go after the original red.

[relantel]

3 - mac (redwill, hammer, malka)
2 - gaucho (benny, shaf)
1 - hammer (mac)

6 needed.

[Willie Kool]

Been too busy this afternoon, I'll need to read up a little this evening before I vote for anyone.

[Gaucho]

I'd be very reckless to act the way I did if I really were a role player. As it is, I'm just carefree. But of course I'd say that.