*** Werewolf XXIII Gameplay Thread ***

[redwill]

On Day 2, the village strung up Sam's Drunk Dog. He was

Spoiler:

a regular peasant.

Bearded, smelly peasants remaining in the village of Malkinimsk:

Spoiler:

columbia
Rylan
DocEmrick
CBear3
MWB
mac5155
Kaizer
relantel
newarenanow
Willie Kool
shafnutz05

Gone from the village:

Spoiler:

Pavel Bure, a regular peasant, was gnawed by wolves more hungry than him on Night 1.
Kraftster, the Alpha Wolf, was strung up, red and dead, on Day 1.
Sam's Drunk Dog, a regular peasant, was strung up by the village on Day 2.

It is now Night 3. RPs, please send me your PMs.

[redwill]

People get ready -- there's a write-up a-comin'.

[redwill]

Night 3 is over.


Once again, it was all quiet along the Eastern front last night.


Bearded, smelly peasants remaining in the village of Malkinimsk:

Spoiler:

columbia
Rylan
DocEmrick
CBear3
MWB
mac5155
Kaizer
relantel
newarenanow
Willie Kool
shafnutz05

Gone from the village:

Spoiler:

Pavel Bure, a regular peasant, was gnawed by wolves more hungry than him on Night 1.
Kraftster, the Alpha Wolf, was strung up, red and dead, on Day 1.
Sam's Drunk Dog, a regular peasant, was strung up by the village on Day 2.

It is now Day 3. With 11 remaining, it takes 6 to lynch.

[MWB]

Interesting. Well, we could go quiet, which would mean Doc or Rel. If not, I'd go with Rylan I think.

[shafnutz05]

Regarding NAN....

In the first day's voting, he came in fifth on Kraftster, where a typical baddie would come in to join the vote late so as to not look suspicious.

Whenever Kraftster made his false role claim, he almost immediately took his vote off of Kraftster and switched it to SDD.

In yesterday's voting, he was third on the SDD bandwagon. However, one thing I also noticed was that he was strongly advocating that there can't be a tie yesterday. While this train of thought makes sense, he was quite adamant about it. The inquisitive side of me is wondering whether he was fine with eitiher CBear or SDD because he knew both of them were blue at worst, green at best.

Also, what came to mind, was when I asked MWB what his train of thought is the start of the second day. NAN chimed in and said we "shouldn't tip the reds off to anything". This makes less and less sense the more I look at it. The reds knew that MWB was the seer. How would him divulging his observations/thoughts to everyone else be negative for the village?

lynch NAN

[columbia]

Interesting. Well, we could go quiet, which would mean Doc or Rel. If not, I'd go with Rylan I think.

Are we assuming that mac is blue, because he hasn't even acknowledged the game?

[newarenanow]

mac or rel would be my choice.

[newarenanow]

[quote="shafnutz05"]
In yesterday's voting, he was third on the SDD bandwagon. However, one thing I also noticed was that he was strongly advocating that there can't be a tie yesterday. While this train of thought makes sense, he was quite adamant about it. The inquisitive side of me is wondering whether he was fine with eitiher CBear or SDD because he knew both of them were blue at worst, green at best.

That's because the idiot village let 3 days of no votes go by two games ago. I just shook my head at that and even though I was mod, it still made me want to pull my hair out.

[MWB]

Interesting. Well, we could go quiet, which would mean Doc or Rel. If not, I'd go with Rylan I think.

Are we assuming that mac is blue, because he hasn't even acknowledged the game?

Sorry, that was supposed to be Mac and rel, not doc.

[DocEmrick]

I was confirmed blue by the seer.

Leaning with shad on this one, don't want to take charge. I thought SDD calling out Kaizer early was a sign of redness.

lynch nan

[MWB]

The tie stuff doesn't make nan look bad to me. Other stuff, maybe.

[MWB]

Im wondering if there was a recruit. In the sign up thread, red said it was a standard game. Now, I don't know how strictly that's being applied, but hasn't redwill talked about wanting regular werewolf games before?

[shafnutz05]

There may have been a recruit, but not two straight nights. I'm pretty sure that on at least one of those nights, the angel was protecting you. Hence, nothing happening.

[newarenanow]

The tie stuff doesn't make nan look bad to me. Other stuff, maybe.

I don't know why the Krafster vote does either. He was pretty much tied with SDD in votes (4-3) and I pushed him to 5 which made him come out. If I was red, then that would be a dumb move. If the vote was like 4-1 or something, then I can see the point shad is making.

Reason I unvoted was I had to go to a meeting and didn't want to keep my vote on him if he was telling the truth. When I came back, teh vote was pretty much done so I didn't bother, but there is no way I can prove that.

[newarenanow]

lynch mac

[shafnutz05]

I really don't think mac is a good choice. He has been posting all over the board this week, including today. I'm convinced at this point he has either forgotten about Warz (bad) or decided he doesn't feel like playing (worse). I find it unlikely, then, that he would have a role that actually piques his interest.

[newarenanow]

I really don't think mac is a good choice. He has been posting all over the board this week, including today. I'm convinced at this point he has either forgotten about Warz (bad) or decided he doesn't feel like playing (worse). I find it unlikely, then, that he would have a role that actually piques his interest.

This is like 3 games in a row he has done this and he continues to sign up.

I'd be more than willing to change my vote to another quiet person, but I think the vig then should shoot mac (if there is a vig) because the longer he passes through the game, the more advantage it gives the reds since he really has no voice in this game and won't participate.

Again, going back two games when I was modding, this almost happened with EPP and it almost hurt the village. We go through this same crap every time, every time it's debated, almost every time in the end, people say it hurt, and yet nothing is ever done about it.

[columbia]

I agree that there is no sense in wasting a day kill on mac.

[MWB]

Kaizer has a handful of posts. First was a vote on Kraft after I outted him. Then a vote on SDD, then took the vote off, then put it back on. In the initial vote, with a single vote on SDD and Kaizer, Kraft made his vote on SDD. Could be nothing to any of this, or Kaizer could be cautious of wanting to post something that gives him away as red.

[DocEmrick]

blue nan
lynch mac

[MWB]

Any chance of a Mac mod kill?

[newarenanow]

I agree that there is no sense in wasting a day kill on mac.

And I'm fine with that as long as he gets shot.

rel
Kaizer
WK
mac

Have been the quietest. I'm fine with any of them.

[DocEmrick]

Any chance of a Mac mod kill?

Unlikely unless mac comes out and flat out says he forgot and doesn't have time.

This could be a trick, shad setting the village up to trust him so people get off mac, who gets lost by the wayside with his lack of participation. I'd rather kill off a non participator, and see what it says about SHAFT first, then go from there.

[newarenanow]

And Rylan has dissappeared.

[Kaizer]

Kaizer has a handful of posts. First was a vote on Kraft after I outted him. Then a vote on SDD, then took the vote off, then put it back on. In the initial vote, with a single vote on SDD and Kaizer, Kraft made his vote on SDD. Could be nothing to any of this, or Kaizer could be cautious of wanting to post something that gives him away as red.

that last part is definitely right, but i also have no experience. I'm trying to sort out all the paranoia into something that makes sense. no matter what role i am, you guys have all these weird signals that would make you kill me, and i dont understand them yet, lol.