*** 1776 Warz Game Thread ***

[columbia]

To quote Rylan: But why should we keep you?

[shafnutz05]

I should also add that Rylan posted "I am suspicious of shafnutz" and columbia voted to lynch me within a minute of each other, at the end of page 5/beginning of page 6. Again, just throwing things out there.

[DocEmrick]

To quote Rylan: But why should we keep you?

Assuming you're a villager.

[shafnutz05]

To quote Rylan: But why should we keep you?

This argument makes no sense. What am I supposed to do here, role claim something? I'm blue. I'm actually trying to make analyses and plays off of documented patterns of play, and I'm getting bandwagoned for being overly active.

[columbia]

To quote Rylan: But why should we keep you?

Assuming you're a villager.

You're assumption would be correct.

[columbia]

To quote Rylan: But why should we keep you?

This argument makes no sense. What am I supposed to do here, role claim something? I'm blue. I'm actually trying to make analyses and plays off of documented patterns of play, and I'm getting bandwagoned for being overly active.

That's an interesting defense, as you went after me for.....being active.

[Rylan]

To quote Rylan: But why should we keep you?

This argument makes no sense. What am I supposed to do here, role claim something? I'm blue. I'm actually trying to make analyses and plays off of documented patterns of play, and I'm getting bandwagoned for being overly active.

Ok, so by being blue you are neither an asset nor an enemy, thus expendable.

[shafnutz05]

That's an interesting defense, as you went after me for.....being active.

No, hardly. I don't go after people for being active. I went after you because you are doing the same exact thing you did when you were red in the last game. As the seer, I outed Slappybrown early in the last game. Immediately, you aligned yourself beside me and offered praise/kudos. This game, you are doing the same thing with redwill.

I want people to be active, so I would never go after someone merely for that. That's how you end up with Warz games where everyone is afraid to talk.

[Rylan]

For the record, not jumping you cause you are active, jumping you because of a few comments.

[shafnutz05]

For the record, not jumping you cause you are active, jumping you because of a few comments.

Comments that I have made in most warz games, and never (or rarely) when I was red?

[IrishEyes]

I don't know if Shaf and columbia are going after each other on purpose, and they're both red, or one's red, or both are blue... but right now, I'm not sure I like the vote for either of them.

@mac... why'd you vote for Rylan? I was leaning that way before I saw your vote, but I don't really have a reason as to why. Just wondering if you had one.

tar and feather Rylan

[Zarovich]

tar and feather columbia

Gonna go with shaft's reasoning since redwill doesn't have anything.

[Malkamaniac]

I believe Shad

[Rylan]

For the record, not jumping you cause you are active, jumping you because of a few comments.

Comments that I have made in most warz games, and never (or rarely) when I was red?

So you have made them when you were a red. Defeating your own defense.

[shafnutz05]

Rylan is offering some extremely convoluted logic right now.

[Malkamaniac]

For the record, not jumping you cause you are active, jumping you because of a few comments.

Comments that I have made in most warz games, and never (or rarely) when I was red?

So you have made them when you were a red. Defeating your own defense.

Everyone at one point was and will be red. It's impossible to not "defeat your own defense."

[columbia]

tar and feather columbia

Gonna go with shaft's reasoning since redwill doesn't have anything.

I'll get more work done this week, if you do that.
But you won't get any further by whacking me.
Maybe the same is true of shad.....We'll see eventually.

[DocEmrick]

unlynch shad
lynch columbia

[Malkamaniac]

The situation here is handling like people are using past experiences to validate themselves. Each game is different and we're not supposed to look at what one person was "last game."

[Rylan]

Everyone at one point was and will be red. It's impossible to not "defeat your own defense."

That's my point, past actions do not foretell future or present actions. I just wish Redwill would tell us who he looked at.

[columbia]

The situation here is handling like people are using past experiences to validate themselves. Each game is different and we're not supposed to look at what one person was "last game."

By that virtue, shafnutz's "reasoning" on me shouldn't be a factor.
But it looks to be going that way.

[relantel]

Vote Count:

4 Shaf-(columbia, ulf, Rylan, twc)
3 Columbia-(shaf, zaro, doc)
2 Rylan (mac, IE)

12 to tar and feather

*rely on past games at your own risk*

[Malkamaniac]

Purely based on this situation? I'm willing to bet that Shad won't make those comments again, even if he thinks they are helpful only because there is this bandwagon mentality that refuses to look at the subject matter, and instead are trying to read between the lines. It's early in the game, if Shad is bad, he's going to expose himself(lol) again, or his words will be proved null by any event that happens in the future.

For that, I'm thinking between Rylan and Columbia, moreso Rylan.

[mac5155]

I don't know if Shaf and columbia are going after each other on purpose, and they're both red, or one's red, or both are blue... but right now, I'm not sure I like the vote for either of them.

@mac... why'd you vote for Rylan? I was leaning that way before I saw your vote, but I don't really have a reason as to why. Just wondering if you had one.

tar and feather Rylan

just a hunch for the most part. some of his actions stuck out as weird to me and ive never played with him before.

[Malkamaniac]

The situation here is handling like people are using past experiences to validate themselves. Each game is different and we're not supposed to look at what one person was "last game."

By that virtue, shafnutz's "reasoning" on me shouldn't be a factor.
But it looks to be going that way.

Which is why right now, I don't think you're bad either.