WWXX GAMEPLAY THREAD

[thehockeyguru]

Malka makes sense, but you dont.

[Willie Kool]

Cause a vote on me makes sense?

At least as much sense as your apparently retaliatory vote on me.

[thehockeyguru]

If my vote was strictly retaliatory then I would have voted NAN last round.

[Juice]

i'll do a quick count...

[Willie Kool]

If my vote was strictly retaliatory then I would have voted NAN last round.

At first, I put the vote on you just to see if you were even here. But the more you post the more defensive you seem.

[Juice]

Benny - 1
columbia - 1
mac - 1
Malk - 7
pavel - 1
thg - 1
willie kool - 1

[relantel]

7 is not 11, and still escapable. But what is the value of letting malka escape? How close until a roleclaim?

[thehockeyguru]

If my vote was strictly retaliatory then I would have voted NAN last round.

At first, I put the vote on you just to see if you were even here. But the more you post the more defensive you seem.

Then why didn't you just say that from the start? My vote on you isn't defensive, its because you aren't making any sense.

First it was

I don't know about columbia. Kraftster and redwill, as good players, would be targets for anyone. At this point I think I like nan's vote yesterday for thg.
Lynch thg

Then it was

At the time of my vote, you were the only player that hadn't posted yet. Not odd at all.

Just make up your mind already.

[Malkamaniac]

7 is not 11, and still escapable. But what is the value of letting malka escape? How close until a roleclaim?

To the village. I'm blue. I'm not doing a malkameltdown, and I'm not role-claiming, it does nothing but kill the village's direction.

[Rylan]

Holy crap this blew up. I don't think Malks is bad. Pavel and shaf seemed suspicious to me but no one else seems to agree...

[PensFanInDC]

Holy crap this blew up. I don't think Malks is bad. Pavel and shaf seemed suspicious to me but no one else seems to agree...

No one?

[Rylan]

Only one vote for Pavel and zero for shaf.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

I have my suspicions for shaf and pavel too, but i'm sticking with Malka for now. If malks turns out to be blue, it will help us make a decision during the next day.

[PensFanInDC]

A few have said pavel is suspicious

[Benny Fitz]

I have my suspicions for shaf and pavel too, but i'm sticking with Malka for now. If malks turns out to be blue, it will help us make a decision during the next day.

[thehockeyguru]

WK or IE are my plays right now.

[Rylan]

I don't understand the vote for Malka though. What did he do that has 7 people voting for him?

[shafnutz05]

I switched to Malk to get the vote moving, since everyone jumped off of my LITT train as fast as can be.

[shafnutz05]

I don't understand the vote for Malka though. What did he do that has 7 people voting for him?

I'm not sure. None of the people that have been outwardly vocal have struck me as suspicious thus far.

Canaan's rationale for going after Benny earlier was a little bizarre, tbh. Like trying to put extra attention on Benny to divert the attention away from someone else. Or, it was an honest mistake.

[Malkamaniac]

lol I do find it overly suspicious that I had 7 votes pinned to me in a matter of 5 minutes.

[Rylan]

Generally when Malka posts, he is blue. Its when he is not posting that generally catches my eye.

thg, why those 2?

[relantel]

Generally when Malka posts, he is blue. Its when he is not posting that generally catches my eye.

that could describe several players quite easily, too many to be of value as an observation

[Pavel Bure]

The game has/had 24 people to start. Lets not act like some eureka moment will come on day 2 of that big of a game or even any game. Usually if someone can be pegged as red on a day 2 it's cause they screwed up and screwed up big not because things get muddled with endless pages of convo. It's basically someone dies, more pieces are garnered from that, and then things can be further figured out. Trying to sort through the dung on day 2 is really pointless. It's a lot of "don't kill me, I'm blue, I'm suspicious of him, lets start a train, finkle is einhorn" The first 3-4 days in a game of this size really just put down voting patterns and B.S. that can be looked at later in the game and be put together like a puzzle.

[Rylan]

Generally when Malka posts, he is blue. Its when he is not posting that generally catches my eye.

that could describe several players quite easily, too many to be of value as an observation

Fair enough. Just spotting thoughts.

[Rylan]

The game has/had 24 people to start. Lets not act like some eureka moment will come on day 2 of that big of a game or even any game. Usually if someone can be pegged as red on a day 2 it's cause they screwed up and screwed up big not because things get muddled with endless pages of convo. It's basically someone dies, more pieces are garnered from that, and then things can be further figured out. Trying to sort through the dung on day 2 is really pointless. It's a lot of "don't kill me, I'm blue, I'm suspicious of him, lets start a train, finkle is einhorn" The first 3-4 days in a game of this size really just put down voting patterns and B.S. that can be looked at later in the game and be put together like a puzzle.

The more people talk though, the more likely it can cause reds to trip up. There is nothing wrong, IMHO, to have solid conversations on different players to see reactions and gauge other players.