BATTLESTAR GALACTICA WARZ Game Thread

[Crankshaft]

2 - newarenanow - Sam's Drunk Dogg, MWB
1 - canaan - redwill
1 - Sam's Drunk Dog - newarenanow
1 - thehockeyguru - canaan

[canaan]

im leaving my vote where it is

[CBear3]

If my bandwagon picks up quickly, just look who started it. I'm an easy bandwagon target and it's an easy vote off for the reds.

Look at the player who claimed green?

Also, why would the reds want you off? So far you've only shown that you'll post votes in this game. That's the type of blue player most reds like having around.

That's why he's after SDD, SDD was the first vote on him.

[slappybrown]

What is suspicious to me about THG's role claim is the fact that he apparently posted part of his alleged PM which he knows he shouldn't do.

[MWB]

Ah, SDD. I thought he was talking about THG, since he seemed to be the one leading the charge against nan.

[newarenanow]

If my bandwagon picks up quickly, just look who started it. I'm an easy bandwagon target and it's an easy vote off for the reds.

Look at the player who claimed green?

Also, why would the reds want you off? So far you've only shown that you'll post votes in this game. That's the type of blue player most reds like having around.

I normally only post votes on Day 1 and Day 2 unless something pops up. I just think it is useless to try to track things down those days and it usually pulls out the greens more often, so I just try to make it simple.

After a few night kills and lowering the numbers, that is where I get more involved.

As for the reds, I'm an easy bandwagon kill. Not a lot of work needs to be done during the day. Everyone likes to "OMG lynch NAN!!".

[newarenanow]

Ah, SDD. I thought he was talking about THG, since he seemed to be the one leading the charge against nan.

I'd vote THG even if he was green. It would make the gaming experience better.

[Crankshaft]

im leaving my vote where it is

Is this because you are counter claiming thg's role or you just don't believe him?

[CBear3]

What is suspicious to me about THG's role claim is the fact that he apparently posted part of his alleged PM which he knows he shouldn't do.

Everybody who role claims basically does this. Rel's PM probably talks about his return from the Quorum too. Maybe he paraphrased, maybe he didn't. It's pretty much the nature of a role claim (especially in a game with solid theme). Neither claim gave their player's identity though.

I'm still not comfortable that both role claims are incredibly vague, but I can't do anything about that.

[canaan]

im leaving my vote where it is

Is this because you are counter claiming thg's role or you just don't believe him?

the latter.

[Crankshaft]

im leaving my vote where it is

Is this because you are counter claiming thg's role or you just don't believe him?

the latter.

I don't like your thought process. Even if he's lying, it doesn't seem like it's worth it to take a chance as a village and voting for a guy that could be good, especially since no one has counter claimed him yet.

You're either bad or you're stubborn. Either way, I don't like it.

lynch canaan

[redwill]

What is suspicious to me about THG's role claim is the fact that he apparently posted part of his alleged PM which he knows he shouldn't do.

This I can get behind. If thg quoted his PM he should be killed on principle alone. He surely knows he shouldn't do that and so I'm inclined to believe it's a false claim.

[slappybrown]

What is suspicious to me about THG's role claim is the fact that he apparently posted part of his alleged PM which he knows he shouldn't do.

Everybody who role claims basically does this. Rel's PM probably talks about his return from the Quorum too. Maybe he paraphrased, maybe he didn't. It's pretty much the nature of a role claim (especially in a game with solid theme). Neither claim gave their player's identity though.

I'm still not comfortable that both role claims are incredibly vague, but I can't do anything about that.

He actually put it into quotes though, and it is so neatly and perfectly arranged to fit the circumstances that it just seems off.

[slappybrown]

This is obviously a tough call, because on one hand (1) no one likes to force a player to clarify the green scope of their role is telling the truth but (2) THG is THG'ing the **** out of this game and should die.

[MRandall25]

The problem also is no one has come out to refute his claim.

[slappybrown]

Also true, but that may be intentional because one of the side benefits to a red false claim is outing greens.

[MWB]

The problem also is no one has come out to refute his claim.

How would one refute a claim that doesn't give specifics?

[MWB]

The other issue with his claim is that it came awfully early. I'm not sure if that makes it more or less suspicious. But the more I think about it, the less I believe him.

[CBear3]

The problem also is no one has come out to refute his claim.

How would one refute a claim that doesn't give specifics?

All the more reason to think its fake...but then again rel got a free pass

[redwill]

unlynch canaan
lynch thehockeyguru

[MRandall25]

The problem also is no one has come out to refute his claim.

How would one refute a claim that doesn't give specifics?

Considering his thing said something to the effect of "protecting the whatever the hell we're called", I think it's safe to say he's probably the angel.

Though I can see where one would think differently.

[CBear3]

Lynch THG. Seems the only way we'll know for sure.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Also true, but that may be intentional because one of the side benefits to a red false claim is outing greens.

Part of me makes me want to believe THG because if he was red it would benefit him more to be more specific and in return hopefully out the actual green player. Although the what he wrote is so vague it could easily be a fake claim. I'm going to hold off until we get another response from him.

[thehockeyguru]

Also true, but that may be intentional because one of the side benefits to a red false claim is outing greens.

Part of me makes me want to believe THG because if he was red it would benefit him more to be more specific and in return hopefully out the actual green player. Although the what he wrote is so vague it could easily be a fake claim. I'm going to hold off until we get another response from him.

I dont want to say anything further. I think it benefits the village the most if the Red's cant pinpoint who is what role and end up wasting a Night on the Angel.

[relantel]

it is obvious to me who thg is. I won't spell it out though.

I'm still inclined for a nan vote. but it's only a hunch from the last vote.