The Dark Knight Game Thread

[slappybrown]

I'm going to lunch, but le wat at what you guys are up to right now

[canaan]

blue sdd
yellow thg

[PensHckyFan79]

oh my I had a busy morning and just read up. I'm going to get some lunch I'll post in about an hour or so.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Two things don't add up for either story:

If slappy was red, how would he know crank was the angel? The only way would be if the reds had a seer and viewed crank. The red seer role is not frequently available.

Slappy had to be really lucky to pick a red to roleblock on night one. He also didn't have a pressing need to come out today.

[thehockeyguru]

So the reds in this game just straight chillax and do nothing? This is your theory.

Pavel, motion to exchange my role block powers for a single vig bullet to shoot THG in his stupid face.

If there was any reference to a role block / night attempt by a red that was thwarted I would tend to agree with you. Pavel hasn't made any reference in any write up. I'm not willing to believe you without some reference. The odds of you role blocking the one person who can kill starting Night 1 is what 1/15?

[thehockeyguru]

I'm not willing to believe you on the 6% chance that you role blocked the correct Red on Night 1. Sorry

[MWB]

Canaan, can you validate anything crank is saying regarding Thomas Wayne?

what hes saying seems to be in line with the pm i received. i was noted as being Thomas Wayne. Him being in my employ parlays into his role. i dont believe i've mentioned that previously

I'm not sure how he would know that unless he got it via pm, adding legitimacy to his claim.

The issue then becomes how did canaan live, if slappy is telling the truth. If he roleblocked crank (who is the angel), canaan would be dead.

[relantel]

I think it quite possible that randall was lying about night 1 kill, and that cranky's protection prevented night 2 kill. Stands to reason then that slappy's claim becomes quite the bit more dubious.

SDD is correct, there hasn't been a red seer in a while, but they used to be common in the 25+ games, moreso than the roleblock role recently reintroduced by Kaizer last game. My gut says slappy is pulling there having been a roleblocker last game to create a plausible claim (before Cranky's counterclaim).

[MWB]

We also don't know that mrandall is being truthful. He may not have killed rylan night one and was trying to say hi did for some other reason.

[Willie Kool]

If slappy was red, how would he know crank was the angel? The only way would be if the reds had a seer and viewed crank.

If the reds tried to kill crank night 1, and crank was saved, it would be pretty obvious...

[Willie Kool]

save crank

[MWB]

save crank

[thehockeyguru]

Why has there been no mention of any role block or attempted Red action?

[CBear3]

Save Crank,
Kill Slappy

He's at the best orange and already outed himself to be killed soon.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

If slappy was red, how would he know crank was the angel? The only way would be if the reds had a seer and viewed crank.

If the reds tried to kill crank night 1, and crank was saved, it would be pretty obvious...

I never said that the reds tried to kill crank. They could have tried to kill someone else and still viewed crank at the same time.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Why has there been no mention of any role block or attempted Red action?

It could be that Pavel is trying to keep us guessing by not revealing too much information. Based on his write ups I think that is very plausible.

[thehockeyguru]

Why has there been no mention of any role block or attempted Red action?

It could be that Pavel is trying to keep us guessing by not revealing too much information. Based on his write ups I think that is very plausible.

I've played in a good amount of games. Never has it ever been that if an action occurs at night and its thwarted, that its not mentioned in the write-up.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

There is a first time for everything. I will at least agree the chances are slim that the reds were roleblocked with no mention of it, but I don't think it should be ruled out as impossible.

[Kaizer]

my head hurts.

[thehockeyguru]

There is a first time for everything. I will at least agree the chances are slim that the reds were roleblocked with no mention of it, but I don't think it should be ruled out as impossible.

I cant operate under the assumption that this is the first time that something like that has occured.

[Kaizer]

kill them both, start with crank. unless hes red, then just kill him.

[thehockeyguru]

kill them both, start with crank. unless hes red, then just kill him.

Now I know you are RED. You cant ax the Angel after he has come out. No one else has said they are the Angel/Doc. We have no reason to believe Crank isnt telling the truth.

[Kaizer]

kill them both, start with crank. unless hes red, then just kill him.

Now I know you are RED. You cant ax the Angel after he has come out. No one else has said they are the Angel/Doc. We have no reason to believe Crank isnt telling the truth.

vote for me then.

[thehockeyguru]

I did. But given whats going on with Slappy/Crank its clear someone is lying.

[MWB]

Why has there been no mention of any role block or attempted Red action?

It could be that Pavel is trying to keep us guessing by not revealing too much information. Based on his write ups I think that is very plausible.

I've played in a good amount of games. Never has it ever been that if an action occurs at night and its thwarted, that its not mentioned in the write-up.

There's also no indication of an angel save in the write up. So do you think there was just no attempt at all?