The Dark Knight Game Thread

[Pavel Bure]

Wow I think I have this, doing it mobile and wrote it down

Cbear - 1 - nan
SDD - 1 - shad
Crankshaft - 2 - Slappy, Kaizer
Slappy - 3 - crankshaft, THG, cbear
THG - 1 - Canaan

8 to lynch, deadline 4:30

[thehockeyguru]

I'm leaning that way. We dont know if there are two separate factions Red/Orange. If they can accumulate kills, ect.

All we know from the write-up is "MRandall was The Joker he lived to create chaos. He just wanted a chance to try out his role." It could be very well that he wasn't a Vig and was the head of a faction.

[newarenanow]

Wow, I come back from lunch and find this.

Nice.

[Willie Kool]

If slappy was red, how would he know crank was the angel? The only way would be if the reds had a seer and viewed crank.

If the reds tried to kill crank night 1, and crank was saved, it would be pretty obvious...

I never said that the reds tried to kill crank. They could have tried to kill someone else and still viewed crank at the same time.

What? Why are you pushing the 'red seer' angle? I'm saying they would know crank was the angel because he saved himself night 1. Who's trying to confuse the village now?

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

Ok I didn't get what you were saying. That makes sense.

[thehockeyguru]

I'm not sure why this is even a discussion. Crank claimed the Doc role. If he wasn't the Doc the real Doc would have come out by now.

[Willie Kool]

Kill slappy

[columbia]

I can't tell how much of this confusion is manufactured, but slappy's story doesn't add up against an uncontested angel claim.

lynch slappy

[thehockeyguru]

Canaan why the vote on me given all that has gone on?

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

kill slappy

I think it is more likely that crank is telling the truth at this point.

[slappybrown]

unbelievable

[slappybrown]

WHY WOULD I COME OUT IF I WERE ORANGE AND INDY IT MAKES LITERALLY NO SENSE

WHY HAVE THE REDS NOT KILLED

I BLOCKED HIM EVERY. SINGLE. NIGHT.

The reds have yet to kill.

[slappybrown]

I can't tell how much of this confusion is manufactured, but slappy's story doesn't add up against an uncontested angel claim.

lynch slappy

Please explain how it doesnt.

[slappybrown]

I'm not sure why this is even a discussion. Crank claimed the Doc role. If he wasn't the Doc the real Doc would have come out by now.

Holy christ are you dense or red.

Clear cranky

lynch THG

[thehockeyguru]

If Crank isnt the Angel who is?

[columbia]

I can't tell how much of this confusion is manufactured, but slappy's story doesn't add up against an uncontested angel claim.

lynch slappy

Please explain how it doesnt.

For starters, now you don't even want to kill crankshaft.
Why should we?

[slappybrown]

If Crank isnt the Angel who is?

Why would the angel come out moron if hes making a false claim. Of course hes claiming angel, because he either (1) will apparently fool you all into buying or (2) force the angel to come out. This is so incredibly obvious.

[thehockeyguru]

The Angel can protect himself each night. There is no reason not to.

[slappybrown]

I can't tell how much of this confusion is manufactured, but slappy's story doesn't add up against an uncontested angel claim.

lynch slappy

Please explain how it doesnt.

For starters, now you don't even want to kill crankshaft.
Why should we?

Why should you what?

Answer my question -- what about my story doesn't add up against an "uncontested" angel claim?

One of two things is true with crnakshaft:

(1) hes red, in which case It seems that both you and THG are trying to move the vote away from him and trying to out the angel.

or

(2) hes the angel, and apparently you are inclined to believe him.

Youre both pushing the "uncontested" nature of his role, which -- why would the angel come out if hes lying.

His story makes no sense, because the reds havent killed.

[slappybrown]

The Angel can protect himself each night. There is no reason not to.

Did you miss the seer claim?

[thehockeyguru]

No

[slappybrown]

Go ahead guys, you can have time to caucus on PM and figure out how to backtrack from the fact that you just tried to out the angel. We can wait for you to draft the proper response to address it delicately.

[slappybrown]

No

So go ahead and explain how your post makes any sense at all. The angel is not protecting himself every night under these circumstances.

[canaan]

Canaan why the vote on me given all that has gone on?

[slappybrown]

I want to hear one plausible explanation for why the reds haven't killed at minimum on one of the nights, and if you ask me, on two of them.