Puck-Lurker wrote: Fri Feb 14, 2025 3:28 pm
ahawk9 wrote: Fri Feb 14, 2025 2:36 pm
So would I. It's not that I don't l ike the player but he serves no purpose with this team in its current situation.
I think the goals of the organization itself - as reported by Dubas and others - are self-contradictory and problematic. I'm fervently hoping Dubas shifts to plan B and does more than just window-dressing rebuilding.
If that means trading one Rakell and Rust. I think that is a healthy move. But without getting robbed; a 1st rounder and top prospect. These guys are very consistent players with a lot of tools in their kit to help a team win. If the return is a 2nd plus top prospect -- pass. A late 1st plus some meh prospect, pass.
I'd like to get a fair return; if for cap reasons, it's a deal that sends more players up and down (see the Pettersson deal), I can live with that. Say.. Rakell, Puustinen and a 5th for some dude with 1 more year on his deal (and some cap hit), a young NHL'er (in the Tomasino mold) plus a mid 1st and 3rd? I don't know, I can appreciate good hockey trades. I think the Pettersson deal was just that.
I'd be fine trading Bunting, if we can trade either Rakell or Rust. Prospects and picks for him.
Karlsson will be very hard to trade without retention, even with the cap increase, 10M is massive. But if Pens were to eat 5M of Karlsson's contract, say, I'm expecting a 1st, good and a middling prospect, a useful young'ish (22-26) NHL player. Throw in Beauvillier and a 3rd. I dunno... don't think teams want to pay nearly as much for Karlsson even at half cap.
The feeling I get from Yohe is, Dubas felt compelled to try and continue the Hextall route his first year here...skirt the line between now and the future. After last year's results, the sentiment is Dubas is no longer trying to please everyone. He's already on Plan B. While Jarry contract, Graves contract, and EK65 trade were poor decisions last year (and EK65 is hard to judge as truly poor for the sole reason of the dead weight Dubas jettisoned in that deal)....I don't think Dubas has made a single bad move this year.
--He traded for Hayes. We may not care for the older player, but he's been better than expected. The true net gain was initially a 2nd round pick, and then Dubas doubled down and turned that 2nd in 2025 to a 2nd in the better draft, 2026, and picked up an additional 3rd rounder...all for a 5th round pick. BIG WIN.
--He got Cody Glass. Again, you don't have to love the player, but he gave up a minor leaguer who was never going to see the light of day at the NHL level, and he got Glass, a 3rd and a 6th in return. BIG WIN.
--He got McGroarty for Yager. Simply going by Athletic prospect rankings, the Penguins upgraded 15 spots. McGroarty ranked 44th prospect by Athletic, Yager 61st. McGroarty has already played a handful of NHL games before Yager. He should be on our roster next year. Doubtful Yager goes straight to NHL without some pro AHL experience first. BIG WIN.
--He got Tomasino for a 4th. BIG WIN
--He got a 1st round pick for 2 expiring UFAs, plus two other serviceable contracts in Desharnais and Heinen, who we can keep this year or flip them this year or next year. GRAND SLAM!
--He brought back POJ for nothing.
--He signed Beauvillier and Grzelcyk to cheap 1 year deals, which he can likely use to gain more picks via trade at the deadline.
--He just plucked a 23 year old smooth skating, defense first, physical hitter d-man off of waivers from Utah.
I don't see a bad move in the bunch this year. He's on Plan B. Trading Rakell at the deadline for a solid offer that includes a 2026 1st or 2026 2nd and top prospect/young NHLer will be icing on the cake.