*** Wars of Beleriand Game Thread ***

[dodint]

Well. That certainly clears everything up, doesn't it?

[ulf]

lol didn't MRandall25 tell us he could only be protected once?

[ulf]

Although I suppose that was a good play on his part.

[dodint]

I imagine he could still be protected by someone else.

[PensFanInDC]

Troy Loney or MWB...

One of them is red I think. TL voted for MRandall and MWB didn't vote at all.

[MWB]

the first priority should be to get reds (duh). I think the second priority is to kill orange. I don't trust mrandall at all, and also think sdd is orange.
My reference to mythology earlier was the redwill stressed it in his post, leading me to believe that it shouldn't be taken as fact for this game. I certainly could have misinterpreted it though.

[ulf]

I imagine he could still be protected by someone else.

Also a good point as it seems there's like 9 players with powers.

[MWB]

Troy Loney or MWB...

One of them is red I think. TL voted for MRandall and MWB didn't vote at all.

Nope, haven't voted all game. Care to expand on why either of us is red beyond the vote?

[PensFanInDC]

Troy Loney or MWB...

One of them is red I think. TL voted for MRandall and MWB didn't vote at all.

Nope, haven't voted all game. Care to expand on why either of us is red beyond the vote?

No.

Although you not voting AT ALL is reason enough for me to want to kill you.

[dodint]

I'll cast the first stone. I feel like the orange folks have ulterior motives. MR25 is orange, and despite many attempts, can't seemed to be killed at night. Let us try during the Day.

lynch MRandall25

[MWB]

Timing has been bad in terms of when I'm on and I haven't had a good read on the game. I read up over the weekend, and am now done with testing.

[Willie Kool]

Yeah, what's up with that? Not voting really doesn't help the rest of us.

[MWB]

I'll cast the first stone. I feel like the orange folks have ulterior motives. MR25 is orange, and despite many attempts, can't seemed to be killed at night. Let us try during the Day.

lynch MRandall25

Mr said the motive is to get the silmarils. This makes sense. He says it is impossible to achieve that now with shaf dead, and they can only help the village. That is improbable.

[obhave]

Im thinking pfidc is the right play. He didnt vote for canaan or mac. Seems suspicious, no?

Also could be down for a mrandall vote.

[MWB]

Yeah, what's up with that? Not voting really doesn't help the rest of us.

Asked and answered. Next question!

[PensFanInDC]

Randall has been honest about everything so far and there is evidence to back that up. I don't want to mark him as bad just because his color is orange and he had been protected at night (something he had been totally honest about). In my experience the reds (or baddies) try to lie their way through. Honesty, when proven by actions, usually lends to innocence. I am not saying he is 100% good but he has been open and honest about his role.

[dodint]

My thinking is the orange clan wants the gems more than the village. I'll change my vote if something interesting comes to light, but for right now with nothing else out there I'm happy with this choice.

[PensFanInDC]

Timing has been bad in terms of when I'm on and I haven't had a good read on the game. I read up over the weekend, and am now done with testing.

I'll allow it

[Crankshaft]

Im thinking pfidc is the right play. He didnt vote for canaan or mac. Seems suspicious, no?

Also could be down for a mrandall vote.

I've had a gut feeling re: PFiDC but haven't had enough "proof" to really put it out there.

With that said, I'd vote for him.

[MWB]

Randall has been honest about everything so far and there is evidence to back that up. I don't want to mark him as bad just because his color is orange and he had been protected at night (something he had been totally honest about). In my experience the reds (or baddies) try to lie their way through. Honesty, when proven by actions, usually lends to innocence. I am not saying he is 100% good but he has been open and honest about his role.

How could we possibly know he has been honest? There is some stuff that was provable. There is also a lot of stuff that we have no idea about.

[ulf]

Im thinking pfidc is the right play. He didnt vote for canaan or mac. Seems suspicious, no?

Also could be down for a mrandall vote.

I've had a gut feeling re: PFiDC but haven't had enough "proof" to really put it out there.

With that said, I'd vote for him.

There's a "baddie" post if I've ever seen one

[PensFanInDC]

Randall has been honest about everything so far and there is evidence to back that up. I don't want to mark him as bad just because his color is orange and he had been protected at night (something he had been totally honest about). In my experience the reds (or baddies) try to lie their way through. Honesty, when proven by actions, usually lends to innocence. I am not saying he is 100% good but he has been open and honest about his role.

How could we possibly know he has been honest? There is some stuff that was provable. There is also a lot of stuff that we have no idea about.

He was honest about Slappy's role (unless he and slappy are in cahoots)
He was honest about his color being orange and Shaf being part of his clan
He was honest about his ability to be protected at night

I'm not saying everything he said is infallible but it's been pretty spot on so far.

[dodint]

Yeah, I'm with MWB. I don't buy everything MR25 is saying to be truth just because it's interesting.

[PensFanInDC]

Im thinking pfidc is the right play. He didnt vote for canaan or mac. Seems suspicious, no?

Also could be down for a mrandall vote.

I've had a gut feeling re: PFiDC but haven't had enough "proof" to really put it out there.

With that said, I'd vote for him.

Your gut sucks

[CBear3]

Naw, I think PFiDC is orange with MRandall
Dodint and BigMcK seem together (probably blue with Zaro).