*** Wars of Beleriand Game Thread ***

[dodint]

Ah, well, F me then. That changes things for me. hmm. I have to look that up.

[Willie Kool]

Didnt cbear claim blue at some point? Or villager? My guess is he is not blue if he just voted for wk. Im on my phone and cant search for cbears posts.

CBear claimed plain villager - no PM. He didn't give a color. I'm light blue - House of Fingolfin.

[dodint]

I don't believe I ever claimed blue;
I said I was a villager, running around blind int he dark because I may be the only person who didn't get a freakin' PM on how to win the game

Yeah, CBear3 claimed 'villager' which I equated as blue. My mistake.

[dodint]

5th Day - 8 to kill

5 relental - dodint, PFiDC, Zarovich, Kaizer, ulf
1 Willie Kool - MWB

[MWB]

OK, so maybe it's time to step back.

What is good for the village?

Do we want to find the last orange?
Are we trying to find the last red?

Will Zaro confirm WK?

Umm both? I think zaro said WK is a bad vote, while MWB appears to think otherwise. I'm staying with rel until I see something with a little more detail

Not going to provide more detail. Sorry.
Zaro basically said wk is with him. I will rescind my vote in him as I'd rather get orange or yellow, if we can't get red. That said
Save wk
Kill sdd

Color me

[MWB]

I'd also go pfidc or ulf, as I think one could be red.

[MWB]

Or TWC.

[CBear3]

Zaro claims he's not for a WK vote, not necessarily the same as backing him as a "good guy." Could be splitting hairs, but you never know.

MWB doesn't like the rel vote, and as said before I feel confident MWB is in the house of Doriath which doesn't seem to be a danger to the village.
That leaves me this list:

PFIDC
Sam's Drunk Dog
the wicked child
ulf
Kaizer

If I'm right, there's only 1 red and 1 orange left. They have nobody to consort with so any claim they make wouldn't be corroborated.

[PensFanInDC]

OK, so maybe it's time to step back.

What is good for the village?

Do we want to find the last orange?
Are we trying to find the last red?

Will Zaro confirm WK?

Umm both? I think zaro said WK is a bad vote, while MWB appears to think otherwise. I'm staying with rel until I see something with a little more detail

Not going to provide more detail. Sorry.
Zaro basically said wk is with him. I will rescind my vote in him as I'd rather get orange or yellow, if we can't get red. That said
Save wk
Kill sdd

Color me

[dodint]

Save wk

Kill sdd

Color me

[ulf]

I'd also go pfidc or ulf, as I think one could be red.

Man if I didn't know you were good, you'd be an easy vote. voted for two people already and named two others. A few more and you'd have half the remaining people mentioned ;)

[CBear3]

OK, so maybe it's time to step back.

What is good for the village?

Do we want to find the last orange?
Are we trying to find the last red?

Will Zaro confirm WK?

Umm both? I think zaro said WK is a bad vote, while MWB appears to think otherwise. I'm staying with rel until I see something with a little more detail

Not going to provide more detail. Sorry.
Zaro basically said wk is with him. I will rescind my vote in him as I'd rather get orange or yellow, if we can't get red. That said
Save wk
Kill sdd

Color me

Is there something we should know about yellows? Slappy's already "confirmed" as one.

[relantel]

save cbear


lynch relantel

Very quiet, not helping at all, lives in Virginia, watches Bones

eh, can't win em all. Sped through season 7 last night... then couldn't quit on the cliffhanger into season 8. TV with netflix not near the laptop (for LGP) - different floors - so it's catchup at work. I'm ok with your first two observations as (albeit misguided) reasons but leave the latter two out of it.

Being near the brink, a vote for me is a vote in support of the red/orange cause, and against the blue/green cause. I won't give particulars at this point, as that would only help the red/orange cause. Much fight beyond this only helps the red/orange cause as well.

[MWB]

I'd also go pfidc or ulf, as I think one could be red.

Man if I didn't know you were good, you'd be an easy vote. voted for two people already and named two others. A few more and you'd have half the remaining people mentioned ;)

Can you clarify this? I'm only asking because I can't go back and look right now. I don't remember who you voted for or named.

[ulf]

I was talking about you.

Anyway, blue rel. Gotta re read some things.

[Willie Kool]

I'd also go pfidc or ulf, as I think one could be red.

Man if I didn't know you were good, you'd be an easy vote. voted for two people already and named two others. A few more and you'd have half the remaining people mentioned

Can you clarify this? I'm only asking because I can't go back and look right now. I don't remember who you voted for or named.

He's saying that YOU voted for two and named two others.

[MWB]

Oh. Well, yeah. Isn't that kind of how the game is played?

[dodint]

I was talking about you.

Anyway, blue rel. Gotta re read some things.

5th Day - 8 to kill

4 relental - dodint, PFiDC, Zarovich, Kaizer
1 SDD - MWB

[CBear3]

Yellow ulf

He goes after WK, so he's not blue.
He then switches to BigMcK, whom I believe was defended strongly by dodint/obhave/etc which lines up with the blue green cause.
My guess is he's the last red.
Drops in after the mac kill as saying "he didn't see that coming."

[dodint]

I've been itchy about ulf but I give people a lot of leeway when they talk more. You could be onto something.

I felt strongly about rel AND WK, so either I'm a horrible judge of character or one (or both) just bailed themselves out. I'm going into a holding pattern (well, lunch) so I'll think stuff over and check back in a bit.

[CBear3]

He also pulled a "that's a baddie post if I ever saw one" on Crankshaft. Who admittedly was orange, but pointing out a baddie post to try to distance himself seems like a possible play.

[ulf]

He also pulled a "that's a baddie post if I ever saw one" on Crankshaft. Who admittedly was orange, but pointing out a baddie post to try to distance himself seems like a possible play.

Ahh yes the old "call out your partner who has no heat on him trick"

[CBear3]

I was claiming you were the fourth red, and as far as I know the red's haven't colluded with the oranges.

[CBear3]

I mean, I could be totally wrong I'll admit.
It hinges on the belief that either dodint/obhave knew BigMcK was good which isn't stated anywhere, It's just my gut feeling of how they continually tried to protect him from a vote.

[the wicked child]

Haven't had any time to go back and look at voting patterns, but ulf and SDD are jumping out at me for some reason.

Not going to vote until I look into it more.