BATTLESTAR GALACTICA WARZ Game Thread

[MWB]

I'm thinking mrandall.

[MRandall25]

You'd be wrong.

[MWB]

I've been wrong a lot, so I'm used to it.

[CBear3]

Aha, so they were both full of it. At least rel was green.

[redwill]

I guess relantel couldn't save himself last night? Or maybe he figgered they wouldn't go for him...?

[redwill]

... And how did he know exactly who thg was?

Doesn't matter in the big picture, I suppose, but there was perhaps more to relantel's role than the write-up gave us.

[MRandall25]

Perhaps the greens are allowed to communicate w/ each other?

[MWB]

Perhaps the greens are allowed to communicate w/ each other?

That would be the logical conclusion.

[redwill]

lynch CBear3

[Crankshaft]

lynch CBear3

Why?

[redwill]

Why?

To make you ask ques ... oh, nevermind.

[MWB]

You'll make me do nothing, redwill!

[Kaizer]

1 CBear - redwill

no time limit.

[CBear3]

1. SDD
2. MRandall
4. MWB
9. redwill
11. CBear
12. Slappy
17. crankshaft


Somebody out of that group is the real seer who communicated with rel. Somebody is the last red.

On mobile, so bear with me.
I think Crank was on both Canaan and THG early.
slappy was on THG like white on rice.
SDD led the vote on THG multiple times.

So that leaves MWB, redwill, and MRandall (and me)

Of the three, obviously redwill is the hardest to read because he has cryptic votes. MRandall has been floundering a more than usual. MWB has been his usual self, very talkative whether he's right or not. Obviously I haven't been of much help either.

I think I'd lean to MRandall.

Interesting thing I just thought of, if the greens could talk they would have known THG was a fraud from the beginning. Hmm

[MRandall25]

I still think redwill is red.

[redwill]

You'd be wrong.

[slappybrown]

I want to vote for redwill because he's been a useless moron this game, but (1) that'd be selfish and (2) have a feeling about MR.

CBear I don't have a good read on. Need to go back through when not on my phone and see what he's done.

[redwill]

I want to vote for redwill because he's been a useless moron this game

Go ahead. You deserve it.

[MRandall25]

Thinking about it, and looking back on votes (ignoring the typical redwill stuff) I think redwill is clear.

IMO, I think CBear is trying to play you guys by pointing the finger at me. I know I'm not red, but that's not going to make you guys feel good about me.

We can't go by who is/was leading the vote on THG, because Canaan was the first vote on him during the day phase we killed NAN.

I'd also like to hear back from Shad since he's been resurrected. Would be nice to see what his perspective has been sitting back and watching everything.

[MWB]

If my count is correct, cbear has two votes all game. He voted for columbia day two, then voted for thg, during the nan vote. However, that thg vote came when nan already had 5 votes on him. He seems to be playing the middle in many of his posts.

[shafnutz05]

When cbear voted for THG, canaan was the first vote on thg. The two other reds (presumably) coming in as the first two votes on their own teammate would certainly be unprecedented as far as I can remember.

[redwill]

When cbear voted for THG, canaan was the first vote on thg. The two other reds (presumably) coming in as the first two votes on their own teammate would certainly be unprecedented as far as I can remember.

While that's an excellent point, he was in fact the third vote (I was second) and it was after thg had made his claim and that claim was being challenged. It's not impossible that they saw that thg's claim wouldn't hold up and so got on the thg vote quick.

Anyway, I'm only going on a vague hunch with CBear.

[shafnutz05]

Tis very true. Balancing the sacrifice of one of your own against establishing long term cred.

[Sam's Drunk Dog]

lynch cbear

By reading everyone's posts and the votes, I've narrowed it down to him or crankshaft. Mrandall and thg were going at it to much to be both red. Crankshaft was vocal about thg too. cbear was largely quiet and never voted for thg after I made it pretty obvious that thg was red. He even chimed in but never placed a vote.

[Crankshaft]

Hope the Reds destroy y'all. That's the stupidest day one vote by the village I've ever witnessed.

Going back through the thread. I got a laugh out of this again. Figured I'd repost.