The Dark Knight Game Thread

[PensHckyFan79]

I am going to laugh and laugh when canaan dies tonite.

ive thought of this also, someone mentioned we have a seer but crank will have to protect himself if he is the angel, thus leaving canaan exposed.

[slappybrown]

All you are going to learn is that I am green.

Then we'll know that and can move forward accordingly.

Of course, but why would you vote for the person who's story checks out when you are not voting for the person who's story doesnt? He protected canaan on night 2, but the reds didn't kill him. Who did the reds target then? Why didnt anyone die?

What really happened is I blocked him, they didn't kill knan, and the real angel protected canaan. Thats logical. What you guys are proposing with respect to me makes zero sense.

No matter what crankshafts power is, he was unable to use it on night 1 and 2. So on night 2, he allegedly protected canaan.

Either:

crankshaft is red and so canaan didnt die

or

the reds stayed away from canaan and killed...no one????? lololol

Do you not see the gaping holes in this story? I said I roleblocked him the first two nights from the start here. If you think I so perfectly am playing you as a red by mind reading what his reaction would be and subsequent story, I am not that good.

[newarenanow]

This will be a major cluster if there is no angel and only a role blocker.

Other than that, I'm inclined to believe Crank over slappy right now because no one else jumped out.

[slappybrown]

This will be a major cluster if there is no angel and only a role blocker.

Other than that, I'm inclined to believe Crank over slappy right now because no one else jumped out.

WHY WHY WHY would the angel come out???????????????????????

[Crankshaft]

All you are going to learn is that I am green.

Then we'll know that and can move forward accordingly.

Of course, but why would you vote for the person who's story checks out when you are not voting for the person who's story doesnt? He protected canaan on night 2, but the reds didn't kill him. Who did the reds target then? Why didnt anyone die?

What really happened is I blocked him, they didn't kill knan, and the real angel protected canaan. Thats logical. What you guys are proposing with respect to me makes zero sense.

No matter what crankshafts power is, he was unable to use it on night 1 and 2. So on night 2, he allegedly protected canaan.

Either:

crankshaft is red and so canaan didnt die

or

the reds stayed away from canaan and killed...no one????? lololol

Do you not see the gaping holes in this story? I said I roleblocked him the first two nights from the start here. If you think I so perfectly am playing you as a red by mind reading what his reaction would be and subsequent story, I am not that good.

How do you explain the Thomas Wayne connection that I alluded to and canaan substantiated? You conveniently gloss over that.

[columbia]

This will be a major cluster if there is no angel and only a role blocker.

Other than that, I'm inclined to believe Crank over slappy right now because no one else jumped out.

WHY WHY WHY would the angel come out???????????????????????

He already has.

[slappybrown]

I explained it. You created a role claim and filled it in with Thomas Wayne's backstory. I've done in the past too in other games, as have countless others.

[newarenanow]

This will be a major cluster if there is no angel and only a role blocker.

Other than that, I'm inclined to believe Crank over slappy right now because no one else jumped out.

WHY WHY WHY would the angel come out???????????????????????

Because it would mean an automatic red kill for the village, clear up confusion, and also allow canaan to clear you up.

THis is a small game. We only have like 12 people left. Assuming there are 3 reds, we need to get things right much earlier than normal.

[slappybrown]

This will be a major cluster if there is no angel and only a role blocker.

Other than that, I'm inclined to believe Crank over slappy right now because no one else jumped out.

WHY WHY WHY would the angel come out???????????????????????

He already has.

No -- he's saying:

IF no one else came out as angel THEN I am lying.

Thats not the same thing as your point, and his logically weak.

[slappybrown]

welp, we hit the deadline. Russian roulette time.

[columbia]

I believe that we passed the deadline.

[MWB]

I am going to laugh and laugh when canaan dies tonite.

I'm amazed that you think everyone should just believe you so easily.

[newarenanow]

I am going to laugh and laugh when canaan dies tonite.

I'm amazed that you think everyone should just believe you so easily.

slappy is butthurt.

[slappybrown]

I am going to laugh and laugh when canaan dies tonite.

I'm amazed that you think everyone should just believe you so easily.

Because the context and timing plainly point to non-red/orange.

[slappybrown]

I am going to laugh and laugh when canaan dies tonite.

I'm amazed that you think everyone should just believe you so easily.

slappy is butthurt.

lololol

Is this game your way of getting back at me for making fun of you all the time? Well, making me becoming dead is your way of extracting some revenge, far be it from me to stand in your way.

[MWB]

I explained it. You created a role claim and filled it in with Thomas Wayne's backstory. I've done in the past too in other games, as have countless others.

If he did that out of the blue, kudos to him, because it matched canaan. The plausible story is that as a red he had some reference to Wayne in his pm and changed it for the role claim.

[newarenanow]

I am going to laugh and laugh when canaan dies tonite.

I'm amazed that you think everyone should just believe you so easily.

slappy is butthurt.

lololol

Is this game your way of getting back at me for making fun of you all the time? Well, making me becoming dead is your way of extracting some revenge, far be it from me to stand in your way.

Yes, that is my master plan!

Spoiler:

[MWB]

I am going to laugh and laugh when canaan dies tonite.

I'm amazed that you think everyone should just believe you so easily.

Because the context and timing plainly point to non-red/orange.

Which has been noted, but there are pluses to crank as well (Wayne story).

[MWB]

FWIW, I'm in slappy's corner, 70/30. I just don't think we should rush through this and should see if we can get some info tomorrow.

[Pavel Bure]

DEADLINE MISSED NO KILL IS COMFIRMED

Every time a civilization reaches the pinnacle of its decadence we return to restore the balance...

You're defending a city so corrupt we have infiltrated every level of its infrastructure.

RPs get me your stuff

[Kaizer]

well that was a fun read. since THG has called me red 3 times, if he ever makes a role claim with seeing ability, hes full of it.

[Pavel Bure]

Jim Gordon walked up to the scene of a drug bust. Hiding drugs inside stuffed animals meant for children was low but hiding drugs and something else in them was all together odd. After poking around and asking his colleagues what they had found all that was known was that something was amiss within Gotham. No deaths again but still something was wrong. Gordon kicked the last crate of animals knocking a board loose. On the inside was the quote,

Gotham's time has come. Like Constantinople or Rome before it the city has become a breeding ground for suffering and injustice. It is beyond saving and must be allowed to die. This is the most important function of the League of Shadows. It is one we've performed for centuries. Gotham... must be destroyed.

But what does this message mean and why have the usual deaths in this criminal filled city stopped. Jim looked to the sky and said aloud, "There must be something different this time, something I've missed."

Day 3

Alive

1. MWB - Alfred
2. WK - Dr. Jonathan Crane
3. Crankshaft - Lucius Fox
4. Columbia - Two Face
7. Canaan - Thomas Wayne
8. SDD - James Gordon
9. Pecky - Robin, John Blake
10. Slappy - Batman
11. CBear3 - Carmine Falcone
12. Nan - stomach phone guy
13. Rel - Mayor (seriously that's the character's name wtf)
14. THG - Luke Ravenstahl
15. Shad - catwoman
16. Kaizer - Bane

Dead

6. Rylan - Ra's Al Ghul
5. MRandall - The Joker

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch. Deadline is 10AM Monday (due to the long weekend)

[canaan]

I tried to investigate WK but I was blocked.

[Willie Kool]

I tried to investigate WK but I was blocked.

Are you ******* serious? You wasted a see on me with the crank / slappy thing still unresolved?

[canaan]

I tried to investigate WK but I was blocked.

Are you ******* serious? You wasted a see on me with the crank / slappy thing still unresolved?

i have a rationale. give me a bit and ill explain.