The Dark Knight Game Thread

[MWB]

I feel like we're being set up by slappy.

Why would slappy set us up to vote him off? Do you mean we're being setup to vote off slappy?

Maybe he can't be voted off, maybe something happens based on the number of days that pass, maybe he has a skill that is triggered.

[slappybrown]

I have no idea, because this (1) is obviously not a traditional game and (2) I have no idea what his role and (3) I have no idea if his claim is accurate. Why doesn't he tell you what character you are?

[slappybrown]

My last psot was in response to MWB

[MWB]

I have no idea, because this (1) is obviously not a traditional game and (2) I have no idea what his role and (3) I have no idea if his claim is accurate. Why doesn't he tell you what character you are?

Who are you talking about?

[columbia]

I suppose another possible explanation is that WK blocked the see.
Can't buy into it, however.

[canaan]

Its pretty obvious that Canaan investigating anyone other than me or crankshaft is incomprehensible, so I dont think there is any way you can trust him.

I have to agree with slappy here. Canaan's explanation didn't really make me feel any better about it, either.

thats fine and well...if i was trying to be subversive, i wouldnt have told you who i investigated. whatevs.

[slappybrown]

I have no idea, because this (1) is obviously not a traditional game and (2) I have no idea what his role and (3) I have no idea if his claim is accurate. Why doesn't he tell you what character you are?

Who are you talking about?

Was responding to your post below:

Canaan's see and his explanation make little sense, but if bad, what advantage does he gain by saying he saw wk? He could have said he saw slappy and was blocked.

[MWB]

Canaan said he was noted as being Thomas Wayne in his pm. But since he picked the character Thomas Wayne I'm not sure what that really means.

[slappybrown]

I was noted as Batman and picked as Batman.

If he saw you, shouldnt he know your character?

[MWB]

So the claim by slappy that he has blocked crankshaft the first two nights and that prevented kills, thus crank is red, doesn't seem to hold water. Slappy didn't block crank last night and there was still no kill. Does that adjust your position on crank, slappy?

[MWB]

I was noted as Batman and picked as Batman.

If he saw you, shouldnt he know your character?

Canaan, what did your pm say about me?

[slappybrown]

Yes. It tells me I have absolutely no idea what is going on and wouldn't vote for him for the time being. It tells me that he was an RP, but that whatever the conditions are for a kill from red/orange whatever, they have not been fulfilled (or, maybe, they are holding them for some reason, but I think that is less likely).

[canaan]

all it said was MWB is town

all mrandall's said was mrandall is not town

[MWB]

I don't really know what difference my above question makes. Canaan saw mrandall, was told he wasn't town, and that was accurate. He saw me and was told I was town, which is accurate.

[slappybrown]

I don't really know what difference my above question makes. Canaan saw mrandall, was told he wasn't town, and that was accurate. He saw me and was told I was town, which is accurate.

Yes, but it doesn't hurt to ask. I have no idea what information he is or is not allegedly receiving.

[thehockeyguru]

This game has gone in the dumper. Can we get enough people to vote?

yellow slappy

[MWB]

Yes. It tells me I have absolutely no idea what is going on and wouldn't vote for him for the time being. It tells me that he was an RP, but that whatever the conditions are for a kill from red/orange whatever, they have not been fulfilled (or, maybe, they are holding them for some reason, but I think that is less likely).

What did you say the pm back was when you blocked crank?

[slappybrown]

Yes. It tells me I have absolutely no idea what is going on and wouldn't vote for him for the time being. It tells me that he was an RP, but that whatever the conditions are for a kill from red/orange whatever, they have not been fulfilled (or, maybe, they are holding them for some reason, but I think that is less likely).

What did you say the pm back was when you blocked crank?

role blocked, which is supports canaan being the seer given he is receiving the same type of non-message message

[slappybrown]

There's no question that I am the easiest vote and you at least find out I am green. But again, if you look at the timing of the claim and what I said, its an impossibility that I am not who I say I am. I don't think you're going to learn much from the voting patterns given how chaotic this is turning out to be.

[canaan]

Slappy (6) -- SDD, Shad, NAN, columbia, crank, thg

[MWB]

There's no question that I am the easiest vote and you at least find out I am green. But again, if you look at the timing of the claim and what I said, its an impossibility that I am not who I say I am. I don't think you're going to learn much from the voting patterns given how chaotic this is turning out to be.

Of course it's not an impossibility. You have said that this is not a traditional game and we really don't know what to expect. Yet you keep going back to the same defense. No, it doesn't make sense for you to have come out when you did as a baddie, but we don't know what your role says, what different triggers there could be, or anything else. So for you to just expect people to trust you is silly.

[slappybrown]

Its all I can rely on because its the truth. There is nothing else for me to say.

[slappybrown]

And when I say impossibility, Im really saying that logically it makes no sense.

[MWB]

And you'd never lie in a game of wars, right?

[Willie Kool]

So far, everyone seems to actually be the character they chose. Slappy claimed green as the Bat-man, as did crank as Fox. I am actually inclined to believe both. Rylan was Ra's Al Ghul, and was blue, as am I as Scarecrow, but those two 'villians' pale in comparison to the Joker, Bane and Two Face. I wouldn't be at all surprised if columbia (Two Face) and Kaizer (Bane) are both bad.

Kill Kaizer