pens_CT wrote: Fri Apr 05, 2024 1:58 pm
Pitts wrote: Fri Apr 05, 2024 1:30 pm
pens_CT wrote: Fri Apr 05, 2024 1:26 pm
Antonio wrote: Fri Apr 05, 2024 1:18 pm
FLPensFan wrote: Fri Apr 05, 2024 10:41 am
[
Saw a post that Penguins, Avs, Wild, and Sharks were 4 of the 6 final teams for Colin Graf. He chose the Sharks due to the opportunity he'd have to play right away. (I see ONE East team in that list, LOL)
It's funny because if this team was honest about it's state in the short and medium term and if he is an actual quality prospect, he should have been playing immediately here also. We all know however, that it would border on impossible without one major change.
Do you really want to take a guy directly from college hockey and gift him a spot on the NHL roster? I'd rather they just play Poulin instead of him eating nachos in the press box.
To be honest, his play is supposed to be more than NHL ready right now, so, yes? He should at least get the 10 game minimum most others get.
A guy who was passed over twice in the draft, and now he's NHL ready at 22? Again from the Pens perspective, I'd rather see Poulin in the line-up than some college kid. Maybe Graf turns into something, but the hit rate on un-drafted college free agents is pretty low,
There's usually reasons why kids don't get drafted. Could be undersized, could be a skill deficiency, could be poor level of competition. Without looking at an actual scouting report, my first assumption on why is his schooling. In his draft year, he wasn't at Quinnipiac; he was at Union College and his numbers there weren't great. I also think while Quinnipiac has been in the top 15 teams the last 5-10 years, they aren't seen as a college powerhouse like a Michigan, North Dakota, Minnesota, BC or BU.
If scouts were correct on Graf, he likely wouldn't have increased his scoring rate (22 total points in his year 18 playing year) by going to a better team. This is kind of like free development for teams. He's probably not going to play in the NHL in 3-4 years being drafted in rounds 4-7, so let him continue to play in NCAA instead of going to AHL and taking a roster spot. Now that he's grown his game, a team signs him and gives him a shot. I see nothing wrong with this as a potential avenue for development and acquisition of talent.
But you are correct that, for every ZAR and DOC their is an Ethan Prow, Filip Lindberg, and whoever else who has come and gone recently from our team via the college UFA route.