Pitts wrote: Tue Jul 23, 2024 12:29 pm
Pens goalie situation ranked 30 out of 32:
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/564647 ... e-jackets/
Here’s how this will work. We’ve given each of the 32 teams a ranking in three categories: Current goaltending ... Future prospects ... Cap and contracts
Current: 27
Granger: The floor for the Penguins’ goaltending is higher than several of the teams above them on this list. Tristan Jarry and Alex Nedeljkovic are proven commodities, but I just don’t see a ceiling for any goalie in the organization to become a difference-maker in the next three years unless AHL standout Joel Blomqvist makes a big leap.
Future: 18
Wheeler: Blomqvist was one of the better young goalies in the AHL last year and one of the better young goalies in Finland before that. Sergei Murashov is one of the better young goalies in Russia, too. Between those two, the Pens have two strong goalie prospects. I’ve always had a bit of a soft spot for Taylor Gauthier even if he’s more of a No. 4 in the end as well.
Cap: 30
McIndoe: Jarry has four years left at $5.375 million, a major gamble that’s on shaky ground right now. With Nedeljkovic at $2.5 million through 2026, that means the Penguins are on the hook for almost $8 million for each of the next two seasons for goaltending that might not even be league average.
Don't want to sound like a homer, and I don't think Jarry is great but, this just seems like a very odd way to rank goaltending depth of an organization.
Problem #1: You're really ranking Toronto, Washington, Carolina and Chicago ahead of Pittsburgh in terms of current goaltending? Really???
--Toronto has a career backup in Stolarz, and a middle-aged prospect who has 36 career starts...and they are ranked AHEAD of Pittsburgh???
--Washington has Lindgren and Thompson. Lindgren has been good, and so has Thompson...but not lights out. They also have 8 combined playoff games.
--Carolina I don't have a huge argument with...but it's also not like Andersen and Kochetkov are night and day better than Jarry/Ned. Plus, Andersen is 34. If their "current" evaluation is supposed to look at the next 3 years, Andersen will be 37. But sure, ok.
--Chicago...Mrazek and Brossoit over Jarry and Ned? Really???
I don't think I even need to get into other consistencies after that.